Module Cstrategy


A deterministic evaluation strategy for C.

Require Import Axioms.
Require Import Classical.
Require Import Coqlib.
Require Import Errors.
Require Import Maps.
Require Import Integers.
Require Import Floats.
Require Import Values.
Require Import AST.
Require Import Memory.
Require Import Events.
Require Import Globalenvs.
Require Import Smallstep.
Require Import Ctypes.
Require Import Cop.
Require Import Csyntax.
Require Import Csem.

Section STRATEGY.

Variable ge: genv.

Definition of the strategy


We now formalize a particular strategy for reducing expressions which is the one implemented by the CompCert compiler. It evaluates effectful subexpressions first, in leftmost-innermost order, then finishes with the evaluation of the remaining simple expression.

Simple expressions are defined as follows.

Fixpoint simple (a: expr) : bool :=
  match a with
  | Eloc _ _ _ _ => true
  | Evar _ _ => true
  | Ederef r _ => simple r
  | Efield r _ _ => simple r
  | Eval _ _ => true
  | Evalof l _ => simple l && negb(type_is_volatile (typeof l))
  | Eaddrof l _ => simple l
  | Eunop _ r1 _ => simple r1
  | Ebinop _ r1 r2 _ => simple r1 && simple r2
  | Ecast r1 _ => simple r1
  | Eseqand _ _ _ => false
  | Eseqor _ _ _ => false
  | Econdition _ _ _ _ => false
  | Esizeof _ _ => true
  | Ealignof _ _ => true
  | Eassign _ _ _ => false
  | Eassignop _ _ _ _ _ => false
  | Epostincr _ _ _ => false
  | Ecomma _ _ _ => false
  | Ecall _ _ _ => false
  | Ebuiltin _ _ _ _ => false
  | Eparen _ _ _ => false
  end.

Fixpoint simplelist (rl: exprlist) : bool :=
  match rl with Enil => true | Econs r rl' => simple r && simplelist rl' end.

Simple expressions have interesting properties: their evaluations always terminate, are deterministic, and preserve the memory state. We seize this opportunity to define a big-step semantics for simple expressions.

Section SIMPLE_EXPRS.

Variable e: env.
Variable m: mem.

Inductive eval_simple_lvalue: expr -> block -> ptrofs -> bitfield -> Prop :=
  | esl_loc: forall b ofs ty bf,
      eval_simple_lvalue (Eloc b ofs bf ty) b ofs bf
  | esl_var_local: forall x ty b,
      e!x = Some(b, ty) ->
      eval_simple_lvalue (Evar x ty) b Ptrofs.zero Full
  | esl_var_global: forall x ty b,
      e!x = None ->
      Genv.find_symbol ge x = Some b ->
      eval_simple_lvalue (Evar x ty) b Ptrofs.zero Full
  | esl_deref: forall r ty b ofs,
      eval_simple_rvalue r (Vptr b ofs) ->
      eval_simple_lvalue (Ederef r ty) b ofs Full
  | esl_field_struct: forall r f ty b ofs id co a delta bf,
      eval_simple_rvalue r (Vptr b ofs) ->
      typeof r = Tstruct id a ->
      ge.(genv_cenv)!id = Some co ->
      field_offset ge f (co_members co) = OK (delta, bf) ->
      eval_simple_lvalue (Efield r f ty) b (Ptrofs.add ofs (Ptrofs.repr delta)) bf
  | esl_field_union: forall r f ty b ofs id co a delta bf,
      eval_simple_rvalue r (Vptr b ofs) ->
      typeof r = Tunion id a ->
      union_field_offset ge f (co_members co) = OK (delta, bf) ->
      ge.(genv_cenv)!id = Some co ->
      eval_simple_lvalue (Efield r f ty) b (Ptrofs.add ofs (Ptrofs.repr delta)) bf

with eval_simple_rvalue: expr -> val -> Prop :=
  | esr_val: forall v ty,
      eval_simple_rvalue (Eval v ty) v
  | esr_rvalof: forall b ofs bf l ty v,
      eval_simple_lvalue l b ofs bf ->
      ty = typeof l -> type_is_volatile ty = false ->
      deref_loc ge ty m b ofs bf E0 v ->
      eval_simple_rvalue (Evalof l ty) v
  | esr_addrof: forall b ofs l ty,
      eval_simple_lvalue l b ofs Full ->
      eval_simple_rvalue (Eaddrof l ty) (Vptr b ofs)
  | esr_unop: forall op r1 ty v1 v,
      eval_simple_rvalue r1 v1 ->
      sem_unary_operation op v1 (typeof r1) m = Some v ->
      eval_simple_rvalue (Eunop op r1 ty) v
  | esr_binop: forall op r1 r2 ty v1 v2 v,
      eval_simple_rvalue r1 v1 -> eval_simple_rvalue r2 v2 ->
      sem_binary_operation ge op v1 (typeof r1) v2 (typeof r2) m = Some v ->
      eval_simple_rvalue (Ebinop op r1 r2 ty) v
  | esr_cast: forall ty r1 v1 v,
      eval_simple_rvalue r1 v1 ->
      sem_cast v1 (typeof r1) ty m = Some v ->
      eval_simple_rvalue (Ecast r1 ty) v
  | esr_sizeof: forall ty1 ty,
      eval_simple_rvalue (Esizeof ty1 ty) (Vptrofs (Ptrofs.repr (sizeof ge ty1)))
  | esr_alignof: forall ty1 ty,
      eval_simple_rvalue (Ealignof ty1 ty) (Vptrofs (Ptrofs.repr (alignof ge ty1))).

Inductive eval_simple_list: exprlist -> typelist -> list val -> Prop :=
  | esrl_nil:
      eval_simple_list Enil Tnil nil
  | esrl_cons: forall r rl ty tyl v vl v',
      eval_simple_rvalue r v' -> sem_cast v' (typeof r) ty m = Some v ->
      eval_simple_list rl tyl vl ->
      eval_simple_list (Econs r rl) (Tcons ty tyl) (v :: vl).

Scheme eval_simple_rvalue_ind2 := Minimality for eval_simple_rvalue Sort Prop
  with eval_simple_lvalue_ind2 := Minimality for eval_simple_lvalue Sort Prop.
Combined Scheme eval_simple_rvalue_lvalue_ind from eval_simple_rvalue_ind2, eval_simple_lvalue_ind2.

End SIMPLE_EXPRS.

Left reduction contexts. These contexts allow reducing to the right of a binary operator only if the left subexpression is simple.

Inductive leftcontext: kind -> kind -> (expr -> expr) -> Prop :=
  | lctx_top: forall k,
      leftcontext k k (fun x => x)
  | lctx_deref: forall k C ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k LV (fun x => Ederef (C x) ty)
  | lctx_field: forall k C f ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k LV (fun x => Efield (C x) f ty)
  | lctx_rvalof: forall k C ty,
      leftcontext k LV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Evalof (C x) ty)
  | lctx_addrof: forall k C ty,
      leftcontext k LV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Eaddrof (C x) ty)
  | lctx_unop: forall k C op ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Eunop op (C x) ty)
  | lctx_binop_left: forall k C op e2 ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Ebinop op (C x) e2 ty)
  | lctx_binop_right: forall k C op e1 ty,
      simple e1 = true -> leftcontext k RV C ->
      leftcontext k RV (fun x => Ebinop op e1 (C x) ty)
  | lctx_cast: forall k C ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Ecast (C x) ty)
  | lctx_seqand: forall k C r2 ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Eseqand (C x) r2 ty)
  | lctx_seqor: forall k C r2 ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Eseqor (C x) r2 ty)
  | lctx_condition: forall k C r2 r3 ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Econdition (C x) r2 r3 ty)
  | lctx_assign_left: forall k C e2 ty,
      leftcontext k LV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Eassign (C x) e2 ty)
  | lctx_assign_right: forall k C e1 ty,
      simple e1 = true -> leftcontext k RV C ->
      leftcontext k RV (fun x => Eassign e1 (C x) ty)
  | lctx_assignop_left: forall k C op e2 tyres ty,
      leftcontext k LV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Eassignop op (C x) e2 tyres ty)
  | lctx_assignop_right: forall k C op e1 tyres ty,
      simple e1 = true -> leftcontext k RV C ->
      leftcontext k RV (fun x => Eassignop op e1 (C x) tyres ty)
  | lctx_postincr: forall k C id ty,
      leftcontext k LV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Epostincr id (C x) ty)
  | lctx_call_left: forall k C el ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Ecall (C x) el ty)
  | lctx_call_right: forall k C e1 ty,
      simple e1 = true -> leftcontextlist k C ->
      leftcontext k RV (fun x => Ecall e1 (C x) ty)
  | lctx_builtin: forall k C ef tyargs ty,
      leftcontextlist k C ->
      leftcontext k RV (fun x => Ebuiltin ef tyargs (C x) ty)
  | lctx_comma: forall k C e2 ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Ecomma (C x) e2 ty)
  | lctx_paren: forall k C tycast ty,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontext k RV (fun x => Eparen (C x) tycast ty)

with leftcontextlist: kind -> (expr -> exprlist) -> Prop :=
  | lctx_list_head: forall k C el,
      leftcontext k RV C -> leftcontextlist k (fun x => Econs (C x) el)
  | lctx_list_tail: forall k C e1,
      simple e1 = true -> leftcontextlist k C ->
      leftcontextlist k (fun x => Econs e1 (C x)).

Lemma leftcontext_context:
  forall k1 k2 C, leftcontext k1 k2 C -> context k1 k2 C
with leftcontextlist_contextlist:
  forall k C, leftcontextlist k C -> contextlist k C.
Proof.
  induction 1; constructor; auto.
  induction 1; constructor; auto.
Qed.

Local Hint Resolve leftcontext_context : core.

Strategy for reducing expressions. We reduce the leftmost innermost non-simple subexpression, evaluating its arguments (which are necessarily simple expressions) with the big-step semantics. If there are none, the whole expression is simple and is evaluated in one big step.

Inductive estep: state -> trace -> state -> Prop :=

  | step_expr: forall f r k e m v ty,
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r v ->
      match r with Eval _ _ => False | _ => True end ->
      ty = typeof r ->
      estep (ExprState f r k e m)
         E0 (ExprState f (Eval v ty) k e m)

  | step_rvalof_volatile: forall f C l ty k e m b ofs bf t v,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_lvalue e m l b ofs bf ->
      deref_loc ge ty m b ofs bf t v ->
      ty = typeof l -> type_is_volatile ty = true ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Evalof l ty)) k e m)
          t (ExprState f (C (Eval v ty)) k e m)

  | step_seqand_true: forall f C r1 r2 ty k e m v,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof r1) m = Some true ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Eseqand r1 r2 ty)) k e m)
         E0 (ExprState f (C (Eparen r2 type_bool ty)) k e m)
  | step_seqand_false: forall f C r1 r2 ty k e m v,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof r1) m = Some false ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Eseqand r1 r2 ty)) k e m)
         E0 (ExprState f (C (Eval (Vint Int.zero) ty)) k e m)

  | step_seqor_true: forall f C r1 r2 ty k e m v,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof r1) m = Some true ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Eseqor r1 r2 ty)) k e m)
         E0 (ExprState f (C (Eval (Vint Int.one) ty)) k e m)
  | step_seqor_false: forall f C r1 r2 ty k e m v,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof r1) m = Some false ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Eseqor r1 r2 ty)) k e m)
         E0 (ExprState f (C (Eparen r2 type_bool ty)) k e m)

  | step_condition: forall f C r1 r2 r3 ty k e m v b,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof r1) m = Some b ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Econdition r1 r2 r3 ty)) k e m)
         E0 (ExprState f (C (Eparen (if b then r2 else r3) ty ty)) k e m)

  | step_assign: forall f C l r ty k e m b ofs bf v v1 t m' v',
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_lvalue e m l b ofs bf ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r v ->
      sem_cast v (typeof r) (typeof l) m = Some v1 ->
      assign_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf v1 t m' v' ->
      ty = typeof l ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Eassign l r ty)) k e m)
          t (ExprState f (C (Eval v' ty)) k e m')

  | step_assignop: forall f C op l r tyres ty k e m b ofs bf v1 v2 v3 v4 t1 t2 m' v' t,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_lvalue e m l b ofs bf ->
      deref_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf t1 v1 ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r v2 ->
      sem_binary_operation ge op v1 (typeof l) v2 (typeof r) m = Some v3 ->
      sem_cast v3 tyres (typeof l) m = Some v4 ->
      assign_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf v4 t2 m' v' ->
      ty = typeof l ->
      t = t1 ** t2 ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Eassignop op l r tyres ty)) k e m)
          t (ExprState f (C (Eval v' ty)) k e m')

  | step_assignop_stuck: forall f C op l r tyres ty k e m b ofs bf v1 v2 t,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_lvalue e m l b ofs bf ->
      deref_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf t v1 ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r v2 ->
      match sem_binary_operation ge op v1 (typeof l) v2 (typeof r) m with
      | None => True
      | Some v3 =>
          match sem_cast v3 tyres (typeof l) m with
          | None => True
          | Some v4 => forall t2 m' v', ~(assign_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf v4 t2 m' v')
          end
      end ->
      ty = typeof l ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Eassignop op l r tyres ty)) k e m)
          t Stuckstate

  | step_postincr: forall f C id l ty k e m b ofs bf v1 v2 v3 t1 t2 m' v' t,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_lvalue e m l b ofs bf ->
      deref_loc ge ty m b ofs bf t1 v1 ->
      sem_incrdecr ge id v1 ty m = Some v2 ->
      sem_cast v2 (incrdecr_type ty) ty m = Some v3 ->
      assign_loc ge ty m b ofs bf v3 t2 m' v' ->
      ty = typeof l ->
      t = t1 ** t2 ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Epostincr id l ty)) k e m)
          t (ExprState f (C (Eval v1 ty)) k e m')

  | step_postincr_stuck: forall f C id l ty k e m b ofs bf v1 t,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_lvalue e m l b ofs bf ->
      deref_loc ge ty m b ofs bf t v1 ->
      match sem_incrdecr ge id v1 ty m with
      | None => True
      | Some v2 =>
          match sem_cast v2 (incrdecr_type ty) ty m with
          | None => True
          | Some v3 => forall t2 m' v', ~(assign_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf v3 t2 m' v')
          end
      end ->
      ty = typeof l ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Epostincr id l ty)) k e m)
          t Stuckstate

  | step_comma: forall f C r1 r2 ty k e m v,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r1 v ->
      ty = typeof r2 ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Ecomma r1 r2 ty)) k e m)
         E0 (ExprState f (C r2) k e m)

  | step_paren: forall f C r tycast ty k e m v1 v,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r v1 ->
      sem_cast v1 (typeof r) tycast m = Some v ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Eparen r tycast ty)) k e m)
         E0 (ExprState f (C (Eval v ty)) k e m)

  | step_call: forall f C rf rargs ty k e m targs tres cconv vf vargs fd,
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      classify_fun (typeof rf) = fun_case_f targs tres cconv ->
      eval_simple_rvalue e m rf vf ->
      eval_simple_list e m rargs targs vargs ->
      Genv.find_funct ge vf = Some fd ->
      type_of_fundef fd = Tfunction targs tres cconv ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Ecall rf rargs ty)) k e m)
         E0 (Callstate fd vargs (Kcall f e C ty k) m)

  | step_builtin: forall f C ef tyargs rargs ty k e m vargs t vres m',
      leftcontext RV RV C ->
      eval_simple_list e m rargs tyargs vargs ->
      external_call ef ge vargs m t vres m' ->
      estep (ExprState f (C (Ebuiltin ef tyargs rargs ty)) k e m)
          t (ExprState f (C (Eval vres ty)) k e m').

Definition step (S: state) (t: trace) (S': state) : Prop :=
  estep S t S' \/ sstep ge S t S'.

Properties of contexts

Lemma context_compose:
  forall k2 k3 C2, context k2 k3 C2 ->
  forall k1 C1, context k1 k2 C1 ->
  context k1 k3 (fun x => C2(C1 x))
with contextlist_compose:
  forall k2 C2, contextlist k2 C2 ->
  forall k1 C1, context k1 k2 C1 ->
  contextlist k1 (fun x => C2(C1 x)).
Proof.
  induction 1; intros; try (constructor; eauto).
  replace (fun x => C1 x) with C1. auto. apply extensionality; auto.
  induction 1; intros; constructor; eauto.
Qed.

Local Hint Constructors context contextlist : core.
Local Hint Resolve context_compose contextlist_compose : core.

Safe executions.


A state is safe according to the nondeterministic semantics if it cannot get stuck by doing silent transitions only.

Definition safe (s: Csem.state) : Prop :=
  forall s', star Csem.step ge s E0 s' ->
  (exists r, final_state s' r) \/ (exists t, exists s'', Csem.step ge s' t s'').

Lemma safe_steps:
  forall s s',
  safe s -> star Csem.step ge s E0 s' -> safe s'.
Proof.
  intros; red; intros.
  eapply H. eapply star_trans; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma star_safe:
  forall s1 s2 t s3,
  safe s1 -> star Csem.step ge s1 E0 s2 -> (safe s2 -> star Csem.step ge s2 t s3) ->
  star Csem.step ge s1 t s3.
Proof.
  intros. eapply star_trans; eauto. apply H1. eapply safe_steps; eauto. auto.
Qed.

Lemma plus_safe:
  forall s1 s2 t s3,
  safe s1 -> star Csem.step ge s1 E0 s2 -> (safe s2 -> plus Csem.step ge s2 t s3) ->
  plus Csem.step ge s1 t s3.
Proof.
  intros. eapply star_plus_trans; eauto. apply H1. eapply safe_steps; eauto. auto.
Qed.

Lemma safe_imm_safe:
  forall f C a k e m K,
  safe (ExprState f (C a) k e m) ->
  context K RV C ->
  imm_safe ge e K a m.
Proof.
  intros. destruct (classic (imm_safe ge e K a m)); auto.
  destruct (H Stuckstate).
  apply star_one. left. econstructor; eauto.
  destruct H2 as [r F]. inv F.
  destruct H2 as [t [s' S]]. inv S. inv H2. inv H2.
Qed.

Safe expressions are well-formed with respect to l-values and r-values.

Definition expr_kind (a: expr) : kind :=
  match a with
  | Eloc _ _ _ _ => LV
  | Evar _ _ => LV
  | Ederef _ _ => LV
  | Efield _ _ _ => LV
  | _ => RV
  end.

Lemma lred_kind:
  forall e a m a' m', lred ge e a m a' m' -> expr_kind a = LV.
Proof.
  induction 1; auto.
Qed.

Lemma rred_kind:
  forall a m t a' m', rred ge a m t a' m' -> expr_kind a = RV.
Proof.
  induction 1; auto.
Qed.

Lemma callred_kind:
  forall a m fd args ty, callred ge a m fd args ty -> expr_kind a = RV.
Proof.
  induction 1; auto.
Qed.

Lemma context_kind:
  forall a from to C, context from to C -> expr_kind a = from -> expr_kind (C a) = to.
Proof.
  induction 1; intros; simpl; auto.
Qed.

Lemma imm_safe_kind:
  forall e k a m, imm_safe ge e k a m -> expr_kind a = k.
Proof.
  induction 1.
  auto.
  auto.
  eapply context_kind; eauto. eapply lred_kind; eauto.
  eapply context_kind; eauto. eapply rred_kind; eauto.
  eapply context_kind; eauto. eapply callred_kind; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma safe_expr_kind:
  forall from C f a k e m,
  context from RV C ->
  safe (ExprState f (C a) k e m) ->
  expr_kind a = from.
Proof.
  intros. eapply imm_safe_kind. eapply safe_imm_safe; eauto.
Qed.

Painful inversion lemmas on particular states that are safe.

Section INVERSION_LEMMAS.

Variable e: env.

Fixpoint exprlist_all_values (rl: exprlist) : Prop :=
  match rl with
  | Enil => True
  | Econs (Eval v ty) rl' => exprlist_all_values rl'
  | Econs _ _ => False
  end.

Definition invert_expr_prop (a: expr) (m: mem) : Prop :=
  match a with
  | Eloc b ofs bf ty => False
  | Evar x ty =>
      exists b,
      e!x = Some(b, ty)
      \/ (e!x = None /\ Genv.find_symbol ge x = Some b)
  | Ederef (Eval v ty1) ty =>
      exists b, exists ofs, v = Vptr b ofs
  | Eaddrof (Eloc b ofs bf ty) ty' =>
      bf = Full
  | Efield (Eval v ty1) f ty =>
      exists b, exists ofs, v = Vptr b ofs /\
      match ty1 with
      | Tstruct id _ => exists co delta bf, ge.(genv_cenv)!id = Some co /\ field_offset ge f (co_members co) = Errors.OK (delta, bf)
      | Tunion id _ => exists co delta bf, ge.(genv_cenv)!id = Some co /\ union_field_offset ge f (co_members co) = Errors.OK (delta, bf)
      | _ => False
      end
  | Eval v ty => False
  | Evalof (Eloc b ofs bf ty') ty =>
      ty' = ty /\ exists t, exists v, deref_loc ge ty m b ofs bf t v
  | Eunop op (Eval v1 ty1) ty =>
      exists v, sem_unary_operation op v1 ty1 m = Some v
  | Ebinop op (Eval v1 ty1) (Eval v2 ty2) ty =>
      exists v, sem_binary_operation ge op v1 ty1 v2 ty2 m = Some v
  | Ecast (Eval v1 ty1) ty =>
      exists v, sem_cast v1 ty1 ty m = Some v
  | Eseqand (Eval v1 ty1) r2 ty =>
      exists b, bool_val v1 ty1 m = Some b
  | Eseqor (Eval v1 ty1) r2 ty =>
      exists b, bool_val v1 ty1 m = Some b
  | Econdition (Eval v1 ty1) r1 r2 ty =>
      exists b, bool_val v1 ty1 m = Some b
  | Eassign (Eloc b ofs bf ty1) (Eval v2 ty2) ty =>
      exists v m' v' t,
      ty = ty1 /\ sem_cast v2 ty2 ty1 m = Some v /\ assign_loc ge ty1 m b ofs bf v t m' v'
  | Eassignop op (Eloc b ofs bf ty1) (Eval v2 ty2) tyres ty =>
      exists t v1,
      ty = ty1
      /\ deref_loc ge ty1 m b ofs bf t v1
  | Epostincr id (Eloc b ofs bf ty1) ty =>
      exists t v1,
      ty = ty1
      /\ deref_loc ge ty m b ofs bf t v1
  | Ecomma (Eval v ty1) r2 ty =>
      typeof r2 = ty
  | Eparen (Eval v1 ty1) ty2 ty =>
      exists v, sem_cast v1 ty1 ty2 m = Some v
  | Ecall (Eval vf tyf) rargs ty =>
      exprlist_all_values rargs ->
      exists tyargs tyres cconv fd vl,
         classify_fun tyf = fun_case_f tyargs tyres cconv
      /\ Genv.find_funct ge vf = Some fd
      /\ cast_arguments m rargs tyargs vl
      /\ type_of_fundef fd = Tfunction tyargs tyres cconv
  | Ebuiltin ef tyargs rargs ty =>
      exprlist_all_values rargs ->
      exists vargs, exists t, exists vres, exists m',
         cast_arguments m rargs tyargs vargs
      /\ external_call ef ge vargs m t vres m'
  | _ => True
  end.

Lemma lred_invert:
  forall l m l' m', lred ge e l m l' m' -> invert_expr_prop l m.
Proof.
  induction 1; red; auto.
  exists b; auto.
  exists b; auto.
  exists b; exists ofs; auto.
  exists b; exists ofs; split; auto. exists co, delta, bf; auto.
  exists b; exists ofs; split; auto. exists co, delta, bf; auto.
Qed.

Lemma rred_invert:
  forall r m t r' m', rred ge r m t r' m' -> invert_expr_prop r m.
Proof.
  induction 1; red; auto.
  split; auto; exists t; exists v; auto.
  exists v; auto.
  exists v; auto.
  exists v; auto.
  exists true; auto. exists false; auto.
  exists true; auto. exists false; auto.
  exists b; auto.
  exists v; exists m'; exists v'; exists t; auto.
  exists t; exists v1; auto.
  exists t; exists v1; auto.
  exists v; auto.
  intros. exists vargs; exists t; exists vres; exists m'; auto.
Qed.

Lemma callred_invert:
  forall r fd args ty m,
  callred ge r m fd args ty ->
  invert_expr_prop r m.
Proof.
  intros. inv H. simpl.
  intros. exists tyargs, tyres, cconv, fd, args; auto.
Qed.

Scheme context_ind2 := Minimality for context Sort Prop
  with contextlist_ind2 := Minimality for contextlist Sort Prop.
Combined Scheme context_contextlist_ind from context_ind2, contextlist_ind2.

Lemma invert_expr_context:
  (forall from to C, context from to C ->
   forall a m,
   invert_expr_prop a m ->
   invert_expr_prop (C a) m)
/\(forall from C, contextlist from C ->
  forall a m,
  invert_expr_prop a m ->
  ~exprlist_all_values (C a)).
Proof.
  apply context_contextlist_ind; intros; try (exploit H0; [eauto|intros]); simpl.
  auto.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct e1; auto; destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct e1; auto; destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct e1; auto; destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct e1; auto. intros. elim (H0 a m); auto.
  intros. elim (H0 a m); auto.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  destruct (C a); auto; contradiction.
  red; intros. destruct (C a); auto.
  red; intros. destruct e1; auto. elim (H0 a m); auto.
Qed.

Lemma imm_safe_inv:
  forall k a m,
  imm_safe ge e k a m ->
  match a with
  | Eloc _ _ _ _ => True
  | Eval _ _ => True
  | _ => invert_expr_prop a m
  end.
Proof.
  destruct invert_expr_context as [A B].
  intros. inv H.
  auto.
  auto.
  assert (invert_expr_prop (C e0) m).
    eapply A; eauto. eapply lred_invert; eauto.
  red in H. destruct (C e0); auto; contradiction.
  assert (invert_expr_prop (C e0) m).
    eapply A; eauto. eapply rred_invert; eauto.
  red in H. destruct (C e0); auto; contradiction.
  assert (invert_expr_prop (C e0) m).
    eapply A; eauto. eapply callred_invert; eauto.
  red in H. destruct (C e0); auto; contradiction.
Qed.

Lemma safe_inv:
  forall k C f a K m,
  safe (ExprState f (C a) K e m) ->
  context k RV C ->
  match a with
  | Eloc _ _ _ _ => True
  | Eval _ _ => True
  | _ => invert_expr_prop a m
  end.
Proof.
  intros. eapply imm_safe_inv; eauto. eapply safe_imm_safe; eauto.
Qed.

End INVERSION_LEMMAS.

Correctness of the strategy.


Section SIMPLE_EVAL.

Variable f: function.
Variable k: cont.
Variable e: env.
Variable m: mem.

Lemma eval_simple_steps:
   (forall a v, eval_simple_rvalue e m a v ->
    forall C, context RV RV C ->
    star Csem.step ge (ExprState f (C a) k e m)
                   E0 (ExprState f (C (Eval v (typeof a))) k e m))
/\ (forall a b ofs bf, eval_simple_lvalue e m a b ofs bf ->
    forall C, context LV RV C ->
    star Csem.step ge (ExprState f (C a) k e m)
                   E0 (ExprState f (C (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof a))) k e m)).
Proof.

Ltac Steps REC C' := eapply star_trans; [apply (REC C'); eauto | idtac | simpl; reflexivity].
Ltac FinishR := apply star_one; left; apply step_rred; eauto; simpl; try (econstructor; eauto; fail).
Ltac FinishL := apply star_one; left; apply step_lred; eauto; simpl; try (econstructor; eauto; fail).

  apply eval_simple_rvalue_lvalue_ind; intros.
(* val *)
  apply star_refl.
(* valof *)
  Steps H0 (fun x => C(Evalof x ty)). rewrite <- H1 in *. FinishR.
(* addrof *)
  Steps H0 (fun x => C(Eaddrof x ty)). FinishR.
(* unop *)
  Steps H0 (fun x => C(Eunop op x ty)). FinishR.
(* binop *)
  Steps H0 (fun x => C(Ebinop op x r2 ty)).
  Steps H2 (fun x => C(Ebinop op (Eval v1 (typeof r1)) x ty)).
  FinishR.
(* cast *)
  Steps H0 (fun x => C(Ecast x ty)). FinishR.
(* sizeof *)
  FinishR.
(* alignof *)
  FinishR.
(* loc *)
  apply star_refl.
(* var local *)
  FinishL.
(* var global *)
  FinishL.
(* deref *)
  Steps H0 (fun x => C(Ederef x ty)). FinishL.
(* field struct *)
  Steps H0 (fun x => C(Efield x f0 ty)). rewrite H1 in *. FinishL.
(* field union *)
  Steps H0 (fun x => C(Efield x f0 ty)). rewrite H1 in *. FinishL.
Qed.

Lemma eval_simple_rvalue_steps:
  forall a v, eval_simple_rvalue e m a v ->
  forall C, context RV RV C ->
  star Csem.step ge (ExprState f (C a) k e m)
                E0 (ExprState f (C (Eval v (typeof a))) k e m).
Proof (proj1 eval_simple_steps).

Lemma eval_simple_lvalue_steps:
  forall a b ofs bf, eval_simple_lvalue e m a b ofs bf ->
  forall C, context LV RV C ->
  star Csem.step ge (ExprState f (C a) k e m)
                E0 (ExprState f (C (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof a))) k e m).
Proof (proj2 eval_simple_steps).

Corollary eval_simple_rvalue_safe:
  forall C a v,
  eval_simple_rvalue e m a v ->
  context RV RV C -> safe (ExprState f (C a) k e m) ->
  safe (ExprState f (C (Eval v (typeof a))) k e m).
Proof.
  intros. eapply safe_steps; eauto. eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps; eauto.
Qed.

Corollary eval_simple_lvalue_safe:
  forall C a b ofs bf,
  eval_simple_lvalue e m a b ofs bf ->
  context LV RV C -> safe (ExprState f (C a) k e m) ->
  safe (ExprState f (C (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof a))) k e m).
Proof.
  intros. eapply safe_steps; eauto. eapply eval_simple_lvalue_steps; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma simple_can_eval:
  forall a from C,
  simple a = true -> context from RV C -> safe (ExprState f (C a) k e m) ->
  match from with
  | LV => exists b ofs bf, eval_simple_lvalue e m a b ofs bf
  | RV => exists v, eval_simple_rvalue e m a v
  end.
Proof.
Ltac StepL REC C' a :=
  let b := fresh "b" in let ofs := fresh "ofs" in let bf := fresh "bf" in
  let E := fresh "E" in let S := fresh "SAFE" in
  exploit (REC LV C'); eauto; intros (b & ofs & bf & E);
  assert (S: safe (ExprState f (C' (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof a))) k e m)) by
    (eapply (eval_simple_lvalue_safe C'); eauto);
  simpl in S.
Ltac StepR REC C' a :=
  let v := fresh "v" in let E := fresh "E" in let S := fresh "SAFE" in
  exploit (REC RV C'); eauto; intros [v E];
  assert (S: safe (ExprState f (C' (Eval v (typeof a))) k e m)) by
    (eapply (eval_simple_rvalue_safe C'); eauto);
  simpl in S.

  induction a; intros from C S CTX SAFE;
  generalize (safe_expr_kind _ _ _ _ _ _ _ CTX SAFE); intro K; subst;
  simpl in S; try discriminate; simpl.
- (* val *)
  exists v; constructor.
- (* var *)
  exploit safe_inv; eauto; simpl. intros [b A].
  exists b, Ptrofs.zero, Full.
  intuition. apply esl_var_local; auto. apply esl_var_global; auto.
- (* field *)
  StepR IHa (fun x => C(Efield x f0 ty)) a.
  exploit safe_inv. eexact SAFE0. eauto. simpl.
  intros [b [ofs [EQ TY]]]. subst v. destruct (typeof a) eqn:?; try contradiction.
  destruct TY as (co & delta & bf & CE & OFS). exists b, (Ptrofs.add ofs (Ptrofs.repr delta)), bf; eapply esl_field_struct; eauto.
  destruct TY as (co & delta & bf & CE & OFS). exists b, (Ptrofs.add ofs (Ptrofs.repr delta)), bf; eapply esl_field_union; eauto.
- (* valof *)
  destruct (andb_prop _ _ S) as [S1 S2]. clear S. rewrite negb_true_iff in S2.
  StepL IHa (fun x => C(Evalof x ty)) a.
  exploit safe_inv. eexact SAFE0. eauto. simpl. intros [TY [t [v LOAD]]].
  assert (t = E0). inv LOAD; auto. congruence. subst t.
  exists v; econstructor; eauto. congruence.
- (* deref *)
  StepR IHa (fun x => C(Ederef x ty)) a.
  exploit safe_inv. eexact SAFE0. eauto. simpl. intros [b [ofs EQ]].
  subst v. exists b, ofs, Full; econstructor; eauto.
- (* addrof *)
  StepL IHa (fun x => C(Eaddrof x ty)) a.
  exploit safe_inv. eexact SAFE0. eauto. simpl. intros EQ; subst bf.
  exists (Vptr b ofs); econstructor; eauto.
- (* unop *)
  StepR IHa (fun x => C(Eunop op x ty)) a.
  exploit safe_inv. eexact SAFE0. eauto. simpl. intros [v' EQ].
  exists v'; econstructor; eauto.
- (* binop *)
  destruct (andb_prop _ _ S) as [S1 S2]; clear S.
  StepR IHa1 (fun x => C(Ebinop op x a2 ty)) a1.
  StepR IHa2 (fun x => C(Ebinop op (Eval v (typeof a1)) x ty)) a2.
  exploit safe_inv. eexact SAFE1. eauto. simpl. intros [v' EQ].
  exists v'; econstructor; eauto.
- (* cast *)
  StepR IHa (fun x => C(Ecast x ty)) a.
  exploit safe_inv. eexact SAFE0. eauto. simpl. intros [v' CAST].
  exists v'; econstructor; eauto.
- (* sizeof *)
  econstructor; econstructor.
- (* alignof *)
  econstructor; econstructor.
- (* loc *)
  exists b, ofs, bf; constructor.
Qed.

Lemma simple_can_eval_rval:
  forall r C,
  simple r = true -> context RV RV C -> safe (ExprState f (C r) k e m) ->
  exists v, eval_simple_rvalue e m r v
        /\ safe (ExprState f (C (Eval v (typeof r))) k e m).
Proof.
  intros. exploit (simple_can_eval r RV); eauto. intros [v A].
  exists v; split; auto. eapply eval_simple_rvalue_safe; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma simple_can_eval_lval:
  forall l C,
  simple l = true -> context LV RV C -> safe (ExprState f (C l) k e m) ->
  exists b ofs bf, eval_simple_lvalue e m l b ofs bf
         /\ safe (ExprState f (C (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l))) k e m).
Proof.
  intros. exploit (simple_can_eval l LV); eauto. intros (b & ofs & bf & A).
  exists b, ofs, bf; split; auto. eapply eval_simple_lvalue_safe; eauto.
Qed.

Fixpoint rval_list (vl: list val) (rl: exprlist) : exprlist :=
  match vl, rl with
  | v1 :: vl', Econs r1 rl' => Econs (Eval v1 (typeof r1)) (rval_list vl' rl')
  | _, _ => Enil
  end.

Inductive eval_simple_list': exprlist -> list val -> Prop :=
  | esrl'_nil:
      eval_simple_list' Enil nil
  | esrl'_cons: forall r rl v vl,
      eval_simple_rvalue e m r v ->
      eval_simple_list' rl vl ->
      eval_simple_list' (Econs r rl) (v :: vl).

Lemma eval_simple_list_implies:
  forall rl tyl vl,
  eval_simple_list e m rl tyl vl ->
  exists vl', cast_arguments m (rval_list vl' rl) tyl vl /\ eval_simple_list' rl vl'.
Proof.
  induction 1.
  exists (@nil val); split. constructor. constructor.
  destruct IHeval_simple_list as [vl' [A B]].
  exists (v' :: vl'); split. constructor; auto. constructor; auto.
Qed.

Lemma can_eval_simple_list:
  forall rl vl,
  eval_simple_list' rl vl ->
  forall tyl vl',
  cast_arguments m (rval_list vl rl) tyl vl' ->
  eval_simple_list e m rl tyl vl'.
Proof.
  induction 1; simpl; intros.
  inv H. constructor.
  inv H1. econstructor; eauto.
Qed.

Fixpoint exprlist_app (rl1 rl2: exprlist) : exprlist :=
  match rl1 with
  | Enil => rl2
  | Econs r1 rl1' => Econs r1 (exprlist_app rl1' rl2)
  end.

Lemma exprlist_app_assoc:
  forall rl2 rl3 rl1,
  exprlist_app (exprlist_app rl1 rl2) rl3 =
  exprlist_app rl1 (exprlist_app rl2 rl3).
Proof.
  induction rl1; auto. simpl. congruence.
Qed.

Inductive contextlist' : (exprlist -> expr) -> Prop :=
  | contextlist'_call: forall r1 rl0 ty C,
      context RV RV C ->
      contextlist' (fun rl => C (Ecall r1 (exprlist_app rl0 rl) ty))
  | contextlist'_builtin: forall ef tyargs rl0 ty C,
      context RV RV C ->
      contextlist' (fun rl => C (Ebuiltin ef tyargs (exprlist_app rl0 rl) ty)).

Lemma exprlist_app_context:
  forall rl1 rl2,
  contextlist RV (fun x => exprlist_app rl1 (Econs x rl2)).
Proof.
  induction rl1; simpl; intros.
  apply ctx_list_head. constructor.
  apply ctx_list_tail. auto.
Qed.

Lemma contextlist'_head:
  forall rl C,
  contextlist' C ->
  context RV RV (fun x => C (Econs x rl)).
Proof.
  intros. inv H.
  set (C' := fun x => Ecall r1 (exprlist_app rl0 (Econs x rl)) ty).
  assert (context RV RV C'). constructor. apply exprlist_app_context.
  change (context RV RV (fun x => C0 (C' x))).
  eapply context_compose; eauto.
  set (C' := fun x => Ebuiltin ef tyargs (exprlist_app rl0 (Econs x rl)) ty).
  assert (context RV RV C'). constructor. apply exprlist_app_context.
  change (context RV RV (fun x => C0 (C' x))).
  eapply context_compose; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma contextlist'_tail:
  forall r1 C,
  contextlist' C ->
  contextlist' (fun x => C (Econs r1 x)).
Proof.
  intros. inv H.
  replace (fun x => C0 (Ecall r0 (exprlist_app rl0 (Econs r1 x)) ty))
     with (fun x => C0 (Ecall r0 (exprlist_app (exprlist_app rl0 (Econs r1 Enil)) x) ty)).
  constructor. auto.
  apply extensionality; intros. f_equal. f_equal. apply exprlist_app_assoc.
  replace (fun x => C0 (Ebuiltin ef tyargs (exprlist_app rl0 (Econs r1 x)) ty))
     with (fun x => C0 (Ebuiltin ef tyargs (exprlist_app (exprlist_app rl0 (Econs r1 Enil)) x) ty)).
  constructor. auto.
  apply extensionality; intros. f_equal. f_equal. apply exprlist_app_assoc.
Qed.

Local Hint Resolve contextlist'_head contextlist'_tail : core.

Lemma eval_simple_list_steps:
  forall rl vl, eval_simple_list' rl vl ->
  forall C, contextlist' C ->
  star Csem.step ge (ExprState f (C rl) k e m)
                E0 (ExprState f (C (rval_list vl rl)) k e m).
Proof.
  induction 1; intros.
(* nil *)
  apply star_refl.
(* cons *)
  eapply star_trans.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Econs x rl)); eauto.
  apply IHeval_simple_list' with (C := fun x => C(Econs (Eval v (typeof r)) x)); auto.
  auto.
Qed.

Lemma simple_list_can_eval:
  forall rl C,
  simplelist rl = true ->
  contextlist' C ->
  safe (ExprState f (C rl) k e m) ->
  exists vl, eval_simple_list' rl vl.
Proof.
  induction rl; intros.
  econstructor; constructor.
  simpl in H. destruct (andb_prop _ _ H).
  exploit (simple_can_eval r1 RV (fun x => C(Econs x rl))); eauto.
  intros [v1 EV1].
  exploit (IHrl (fun x => C(Econs (Eval v1 (typeof r1)) x))); eauto.
  apply (eval_simple_rvalue_safe (fun x => C(Econs x rl))); eauto.
  intros [vl EVl].
  exists (v1 :: vl); constructor; auto.
Qed.

Lemma rval_list_all_values:
  forall vl rl, exprlist_all_values (rval_list vl rl).
Proof.
  induction vl; simpl; intros. auto.
  destruct rl; simpl; auto.
Qed.

End SIMPLE_EVAL.

Decomposition

Section DECOMPOSITION.

Variable f: function.
Variable k: cont.
Variable e: env.
Variable m: mem.

Definition simple_side_effect (r: expr) : Prop :=
  match r with
  | Evalof l _ => simple l = true /\ type_is_volatile (typeof l) = true
  | Eseqand r1 r2 _ => simple r1 = true
  | Eseqor r1 r2 _ => simple r1 = true
  | Econdition r1 r2 r3 _ => simple r1 = true
  | Eassign l1 r2 _ => simple l1 = true /\ simple r2 = true
  | Eassignop _ l1 r2 _ _ => simple l1 = true /\ simple r2 = true
  | Epostincr _ l1 _ => simple l1 = true
  | Ecomma r1 r2 _ => simple r1 = true
  | Ecall r1 rl _ => simple r1 = true /\ simplelist rl = true
  | Ebuiltin ef tyargs rl _ => simplelist rl = true
  | Eparen r1 _ _ => simple r1 = true
  | _ => False
  end.

Scheme expr_ind2 := Induction for expr Sort Prop
  with exprlist_ind2 := Induction for exprlist Sort Prop.
Combined Scheme expr_expr_list_ind from expr_ind2, exprlist_ind2.

Local Hint Constructors leftcontext leftcontextlist : core.

Lemma decompose_expr:
  (forall a from C,
   context from RV C -> safe (ExprState f (C a) k e m) ->
       simple a = true
    \/ exists C', exists a', a = C' a' /\ simple_side_effect a' /\ leftcontext RV from C')
/\(forall rl C,
   contextlist' C -> safe (ExprState f (C rl) k e m) ->
       simplelist rl = true
    \/ exists C', exists a', rl = C' a' /\ simple_side_effect a' /\ leftcontextlist RV C').
Proof.
  apply expr_expr_list_ind; intros; simpl; auto.

Ltac Kind :=
  exploit safe_expr_kind; eauto; simpl; intros X; rewrite <- X in *; clear X.
Ltac Rec HR kind C C' :=
  destruct (HR kind (fun x => C(C' x))) as [? | [C'' [a' [D [A B]]]]];
  [eauto | eauto | auto |
   right; exists (fun x => C'(C'' x)); exists a'; rewrite D; auto].
Ltac Base :=
  right; exists (fun x => x); econstructor; split; [eauto | simpl; auto].

(* field *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Efield x f0 ty).
(* rvalof *)
  Kind. Rec H LV C (fun x => Evalof x ty).
  destruct (type_is_volatile (typeof l)) eqn:?.
  Base. rewrite H2; auto.
(* deref *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Ederef x ty).
(* addrof *)
  Kind. Rec H LV C (fun x => Eaddrof x ty).
(* unop *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Eunop op x ty).
(* binop *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Ebinop op x r2 ty). rewrite H3.
  Rec H0 RV C (fun x => Ebinop op r1 x ty).
(* cast *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Ecast x ty).
(* seqand *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Eseqand x r2 ty). Base.
(* seqor *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Eseqor x r2 ty). Base.
(* condition *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Econdition x r2 r3 ty). Base.
(* assign *)
  Kind. Rec H LV C (fun x => Eassign x r ty). Rec H0 RV C (fun x => Eassign l x ty). Base.
(* assignop *)
  Kind. Rec H LV C (fun x => Eassignop op x r tyres ty). Rec H0 RV C (fun x => Eassignop op l x tyres ty). Base.
(* postincr *)
  Kind. Rec H LV C (fun x => Epostincr id x ty). Base.
(* comma *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Ecomma x r2 ty). Base.
(* call *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => Ecall x rargs ty).
  destruct (H0 (fun x => C (Ecall r1 x ty))) as [A | [C' [a' [D [A B]]]]].
    eapply contextlist'_call with (C := C) (rl0 := Enil). auto. auto.
  Base.
  right; exists (fun x => Ecall r1 (C' x) ty); exists a'. rewrite D; simpl; auto.
(* builtin *)
  Kind.
  destruct (H (fun x => C (Ebuiltin ef tyargs x ty))) as [A | [C' [a' [D [A B]]]]].
    eapply contextlist'_builtin with (C := C) (rl0 := Enil). auto. auto.
  Base.
  right; exists (fun x => Ebuiltin ef tyargs (C' x) ty); exists a'. rewrite D; simpl; auto.
(* rparen *)
  Kind. Rec H RV C (fun x => (Eparen x tycast ty)). Base.
(* cons *)
  destruct (H RV (fun x => C (Econs x rl))) as [A | [C' [a' [A [B D]]]]].
    eapply contextlist'_head; eauto. auto.
  destruct (H0 (fun x => C (Econs r1 x))) as [A' | [C' [a' [A' [B D]]]]].
    eapply contextlist'_tail; eauto. auto.
  rewrite A; rewrite A'; auto.
  right; exists (fun x => Econs r1 (C' x)); exists a'. rewrite A'; eauto.
  right; exists (fun x => Econs (C' x) rl); exists a'. rewrite A; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma decompose_topexpr:
  forall a,
  safe (ExprState f a k e m) ->
       simple a = true
    \/ exists C, exists a', a = C a' /\ simple_side_effect a' /\ leftcontext RV RV C.
Proof.
  intros. eapply (proj1 decompose_expr). apply ctx_top. auto.
Qed.

End DECOMPOSITION.

Simulation for expressions.

Lemma estep_simulation:
  forall S t S',
  estep S t S' -> plus Csem.step ge S t S'.
Proof.
  intros. inv H.
(* simple *)
  exploit eval_simple_rvalue_steps; eauto. simpl; intros STEPS.
  exploit star_inv; eauto. intros [[EQ1 EQ2] | A]; eauto.
  inversion EQ1. rewrite <- H2 in H1; contradiction.
(* valof volatile *)
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_lvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Evalof x (typeof l))); eauto.
  left. apply step_rred; eauto. econstructor; eauto. auto.
(* seqand true *)
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eseqand x r2 ty)); eauto.
  left. apply step_rred; eauto. apply red_seqand_true; auto. traceEq.
(* seqand false *)
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eseqand x r2 ty)); eauto.
  left. apply step_rred; eauto. apply red_seqand_false; auto. traceEq.
(* seqor true *)
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eseqor x r2 ty)); eauto.
  left. apply step_rred; eauto. apply red_seqor_true; auto. traceEq.
(* seqor false *)
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eseqor x r2 ty)); eauto.
  left. apply step_rred; eauto. apply red_seqor_false; auto. traceEq.
(* condition *)
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Econdition x r2 r3 ty)); eauto.
  left; apply step_rred; eauto. constructor; auto. auto.
(* assign *)
  eapply star_plus_trans.
  eapply eval_simple_lvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eassign x r (typeof l))); eauto.
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eassign (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l)) x (typeof l))); eauto.
  left; apply step_rred; eauto. econstructor; eauto.
  reflexivity. auto.
(* assignop *)
  eapply star_plus_trans.
  eapply eval_simple_lvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eassignop op x r tyres (typeof l))); eauto.
  eapply star_plus_trans.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eassignop op (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l)) x tyres (typeof l))); eauto.
  eapply plus_left.
  left; apply step_rred; auto. econstructor; eauto.
  eapply star_left.
  left; apply step_rred with (C := fun x => C(Eassign (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l)) x (typeof l))); eauto. econstructor; eauto.
  apply star_one.
  left; apply step_rred; auto. econstructor; eauto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
(* assignop stuck *)
  eapply star_plus_trans.
  eapply eval_simple_lvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eassignop op x r tyres (typeof l))); eauto.
  eapply star_plus_trans.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eassignop op (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l)) x tyres (typeof l))); eauto.
  eapply plus_left.
  left; apply step_rred; auto. econstructor; eauto.
  destruct (sem_binary_operation ge op v1 (typeof l) v2 (typeof r) m) as [v3|] eqn:?.
  eapply star_left.
  left; apply step_rred with (C := fun x => C(Eassign (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l)) x (typeof l))); eauto. econstructor; eauto.
  apply star_one.
  left; eapply step_stuck; eauto.
  red; intros. exploit imm_safe_inv; eauto. simpl. intros [v4' [m' [v' [t' [A [B D]]]]]].
  rewrite B in H4. eelim H4; eauto.
  reflexivity.
  apply star_one.
  left; eapply step_stuck with (C := fun x => C(Eassign (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l)) x (typeof l))); eauto.
  red; intros. exploit imm_safe_inv; eauto. simpl. intros [v3 A]. congruence.
  reflexivity.
  reflexivity. traceEq.
(* postincr *)
  eapply star_plus_trans.
  eapply eval_simple_lvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Epostincr id x (typeof l))); eauto.
  eapply plus_left.
  left; apply step_rred; auto. econstructor; eauto.
  eapply star_left.
  left; apply step_rred with (C := fun x => C (Ecomma (Eassign (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l)) x (typeof l)) (Eval v1 (typeof l)) (typeof l))); eauto.
  econstructor. instantiate (1 := v2). destruct id; assumption.
  eapply star_left.
  left; apply step_rred with (C := fun x => C (Ecomma x (Eval v1 (typeof l)) (typeof l))); eauto.
  econstructor; eauto.
  apply star_one.
  left; apply step_rred; auto. econstructor; eauto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
(* postincr stuck *)
  eapply star_plus_trans.
  eapply eval_simple_lvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Epostincr id x (typeof l))); eauto.
  eapply plus_left.
  left; apply step_rred; auto. econstructor; eauto.
  set (op := match id with Incr => Oadd | Decr => Osub end).
  assert (SEM: sem_binary_operation ge op v1 (typeof l) (Vint Int.one) type_int32s m =
              sem_incrdecr ge id v1 (typeof l) m).
    destruct id; auto.
  destruct (sem_incrdecr ge id v1 (typeof l) m) as [v2|].
  eapply star_left.
  left; apply step_rred with (C := fun x => C (Ecomma (Eassign (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l)) x (typeof l)) (Eval v1 (typeof l)) (typeof l))); eauto.
  econstructor; eauto.
  apply star_one.
  left; eapply step_stuck with (C := fun x => C (Ecomma x (Eval v1 (typeof l)) (typeof l))); eauto.
  red; intros. exploit imm_safe_inv; eauto. simpl. intros [v3 [m' [v' [t' [A [B D]]]]]].
  rewrite B in H3. eelim H3; eauto.
  reflexivity.
  apply star_one.
  left; eapply step_stuck with (C := fun x => C (Ecomma (Eassign (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof l)) x (typeof l)) (Eval v1 (typeof l)) (typeof l))); eauto.
  red; intros. exploit imm_safe_inv; eauto. simpl. intros [v2 A]. congruence.
  reflexivity.
  traceEq.
(* comma *)
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Ecomma x r2 (typeof r2))); eauto.
  left; apply step_rred; eauto. econstructor; eauto. auto.
(* paren *)
  eapply plus_right; eauto.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Eparen x tycast ty)); eauto.
  left; apply step_rred; eauto. econstructor; eauto. auto.
(* call *)
  exploit eval_simple_list_implies; eauto. intros [vl' [A B]].
  eapply star_plus_trans.
  eapply eval_simple_rvalue_steps with (C := fun x => C(Ecall x rargs ty)); eauto.
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_list_steps with (C := fun x => C(Ecall (Eval vf (typeof rf)) x ty)); eauto.
  eapply contextlist'_call with (rl0 := Enil); auto.
  left; apply Csem.step_call; eauto. econstructor; eauto.
  traceEq. auto.
(* builtin *)
  exploit eval_simple_list_implies; eauto. intros [vl' [A B]].
  eapply plus_right.
  eapply eval_simple_list_steps with (C := fun x => C(Ebuiltin ef tyargs x ty)); eauto.
  eapply contextlist'_builtin with (rl0 := Enil); auto.
  left; apply Csem.step_rred; eauto. econstructor; eauto.
  traceEq.
Qed.

Lemma can_estep:
  forall f a k e m,
  safe (ExprState f a k e m) ->
  match a with Eval _ _ => False | _ => True end ->
  exists t, exists S, estep (ExprState f a k e m) t S.
Proof.
  intros. destruct (decompose_topexpr f k e m a H) as [A | [C [b [P [Q R]]]]].
(* simple expr *)
  exploit (simple_can_eval f k e m a RV (fun x => x)); auto. intros [v P].
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_expr; eauto.
(* side effect *)
  clear H0. subst a. red in Q. destruct b; try contradiction.
(* valof volatile *)
  destruct Q.
  exploit (simple_can_eval_lval f k e m b (fun x => C(Evalof x ty))); eauto.
  intros (b1 & ofs & bf & E1 & S1).
  exploit safe_inv. eexact S1. eauto. simpl. intros [A [t [v B]]].
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_rvalof_volatile; eauto. congruence.
(* seqand *)
  exploit (simple_can_eval_rval f k e m b1 (fun x => C(Eseqand x b2 ty))); eauto.
  intros [v1 [E1 S1]].
  exploit safe_inv. eexact S1. eauto. simpl. intros [b BV].
  destruct b.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_seqand_true; eauto.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_seqand_false; eauto.
(* seqor *)
  exploit (simple_can_eval_rval f k e m b1 (fun x => C(Eseqor x b2 ty))); eauto.
  intros [v1 [E1 S1]].
  exploit safe_inv. eexact S1. eauto. simpl. intros [b BV].
  destruct b.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_seqor_true; eauto.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_seqor_false; eauto.
(* condition *)
  exploit (simple_can_eval_rval f k e m b1 (fun x => C(Econdition x b2 b3 ty))); eauto.
  intros [v1 [E1 S1]].
  exploit safe_inv. eexact S1. eauto. simpl. intros [b BV].
  econstructor; econstructor. eapply step_condition; eauto.
(* assign *)
  destruct Q.
  exploit (simple_can_eval_lval f k e m b1 (fun x => C(Eassign x b2 ty))); eauto.
  intros (b & ofs & bf & E1 & S1).
  exploit (simple_can_eval_rval f k e m b2 (fun x => C(Eassign (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof b1)) x ty))); eauto.
  intros [v [E2 S2]].
  exploit safe_inv. eexact S2. eauto. simpl. intros [v1 [m' [v' [t [A [B D]]]]]].
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_assign; eauto.
(* assignop *)
  destruct Q.
  exploit (simple_can_eval_lval f k e m b1 (fun x => C(Eassignop op x b2 tyres ty))); eauto.
  intros (b & ofs & bf & E1 & S1).
  exploit (simple_can_eval_rval f k e m b2 (fun x => C(Eassignop op (Eloc b ofs bf (typeof b1)) x tyres ty))); eauto.
  intros [v [E2 S2]].
  exploit safe_inv. eexact S2. eauto. simpl. intros [t1 [v1 [A B]]].
  destruct (sem_binary_operation ge op v1 (typeof b1) v (typeof b2) m) as [v3|] eqn:?.
  destruct (sem_cast v3 tyres (typeof b1) m) as [v4|] eqn:?.
  destruct (classic (exists t2 m' v', assign_loc ge (typeof b1) m b ofs bf v4 t2 m' v')).
  destruct H2 as [t2 [m' [v' D]]].
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_assignop; eauto.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_assignop_stuck; eauto.
  rewrite Heqo. rewrite Heqo0. intros; red; intros. elim H2. exists t2, m', v'; auto.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_assignop_stuck; eauto.
  rewrite Heqo. rewrite Heqo0. auto.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_assignop_stuck; eauto.
  rewrite Heqo. auto.
(* postincr *)
  exploit (simple_can_eval_lval f k e m b (fun x => C(Epostincr id x ty))); eauto.
  intros (b1 & ofs & bf & E1 & S1).
  exploit safe_inv. eexact S1. eauto. simpl. intros [t [v1 [A B]]].
  destruct (sem_incrdecr ge id v1 ty m) as [v2|] eqn:?.
  destruct (sem_cast v2 (incrdecr_type ty) ty m) as [v3|] eqn:?.
  destruct (classic (exists t2 m' v', assign_loc ge ty m b1 ofs bf v3 t2 m' v')).
  destruct H0 as [t2 [m' [v' D]]].
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_postincr; eauto.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_postincr_stuck; eauto.
  rewrite Heqo. rewrite Heqo0. intros; red; intros. elim H0. exists t2, m', v'; congruence.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_postincr_stuck; eauto.
  rewrite Heqo. rewrite Heqo0. auto.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_postincr_stuck; eauto.
  rewrite Heqo. auto.
(* comma *)
  exploit (simple_can_eval_rval f k e m b1 (fun x => C(Ecomma x b2 ty))); eauto.
  intros [v1 [E1 S1]].
  exploit safe_inv. eexact S1. eauto. simpl. intros EQ.
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_comma; eauto.
(* call *)
  destruct Q.
  exploit (simple_can_eval_rval f k e m b (fun x => C(Ecall x rargs ty))); eauto.
  intros [vf [E1 S1]].
  pose (C' := fun x => C(Ecall (Eval vf (typeof b)) x ty)).
  assert (contextlist' C'). unfold C'; eapply contextlist'_call with (rl0 := Enil); auto.
  exploit (simple_list_can_eval f k e m rargs C'); eauto.
  intros [vl E2].
  exploit safe_inv. 2: eapply leftcontext_context; eexact R.
  eapply safe_steps. eexact S1.
  apply (eval_simple_list_steps f k e m rargs vl E2 C'); auto.
  simpl. intros X. exploit X. eapply rval_list_all_values.
  intros [tyargs [tyres [cconv [fd [vargs [P [Q [U V]]]]]]]].
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_call; eauto. eapply can_eval_simple_list; eauto.
(* builtin *)
  pose (C' := fun x => C(Ebuiltin ef tyargs x ty)).
  assert (contextlist' C'). unfold C'; eapply contextlist'_builtin with (rl0 := Enil); auto.
  exploit (simple_list_can_eval f k e m rargs C'); eauto.
  intros [vl E].
  exploit safe_inv. 2: eapply leftcontext_context; eexact R.
  eapply safe_steps. eexact H.
  apply (eval_simple_list_steps f k e m rargs vl E C'); auto.
  simpl. intros X. exploit X. eapply rval_list_all_values.
  intros [vargs [t [vres [m' [U V]]]]].
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_builtin; eauto.
  eapply can_eval_simple_list; eauto.
(* paren *)
  exploit (simple_can_eval_rval f k e m b (fun x => C(Eparen x tycast ty))); eauto.
  intros [v1 [E1 S1]].
  exploit safe_inv. eexact S1. eauto. simpl. intros [v CAST].
  econstructor; econstructor; eapply step_paren; eauto.
Qed.

Simulation for all states

Theorem step_simulation:
  forall S1 t S2,
  step S1 t S2 -> plus Csem.step ge S1 t S2.
Proof.
  intros. inv H.
  apply estep_simulation; auto.
  apply plus_one. right. auto.
Qed.

Theorem progress:
  forall S,
  safe S -> (exists r, final_state S r) \/ (exists t, exists S', step S t S').
Proof.
  intros. exploit H. apply star_refl. intros [FIN | [t [S' STEP]]].
  (* 1. Finished. *)
  auto.
  right. destruct STEP.
  (* 2. Expression step. *)
  assert (exists t, exists S', estep S t S').
    inv H0.
    (* lred *)
    eapply can_estep; eauto. inv H2; auto.
    (* rred *)
    eapply can_estep; eauto. inv H2; auto. inv H1; auto.
    (* callred *)
    eapply can_estep; eauto. inv H2; auto. inv H1; auto.
    (* stuck *)
    exploit (H Stuckstate). apply star_one. left. econstructor; eauto.
    intros [[r F] | [t [S' R]]]. inv F. inv R. inv H0. inv H0.
  destruct H1 as [t' [S'' ESTEP]].
  exists t'; exists S''; left; auto.
  (* 3. Other step. *)
  exists t; exists S'; right; auto.
Qed.

End STRATEGY.

The semantics that follows the strategy.

Definition semantics (p: program) :=
  let ge := globalenv p in
  Semantics_gen step (initial_state p) final_state ge ge.

This semantics is receptive to changes in events.

Remark deref_loc_trace:
  forall ge ty m b ofs bf t v,
  deref_loc ge ty m b ofs bf t v ->
  match t with nil => True | ev :: nil => True | _ => False end.
Proof.
  intros. inv H; simpl; auto. inv H2; simpl; auto.
Qed.

Remark deref_loc_receptive:
  forall ge ty m b ofs bf ev1 t1 v ev2,
  deref_loc ge ty m b ofs bf (ev1 :: t1) v ->
  match_traces ge (ev1 :: nil) (ev2 :: nil) ->
  t1 = nil /\ exists v', deref_loc ge ty m b ofs bf (ev2 :: nil) v'.
Proof.
  intros.
  assert (t1 = nil). exploit deref_loc_trace; eauto. destruct t1; simpl; tauto.
  inv H. exploit volatile_load_receptive; eauto. intros [v' A].
  split; auto; exists v'; econstructor; eauto.
Qed.

Remark assign_loc_trace:
  forall ge ty m b ofs bf t v m' v',
  assign_loc ge ty m b ofs bf v t m' v' ->
  match t with nil => True | ev :: nil => output_event ev | _ => False end.
Proof.
  intros. inv H; simpl; auto. inv H2; simpl; auto.
Qed.

Remark assign_loc_receptive:
  forall ge ty m b ofs bf ev1 t1 v m' v' ev2,
  assign_loc ge ty m b ofs bf v (ev1 :: t1) m' v' ->
  match_traces ge (ev1 :: nil) (ev2 :: nil) ->
  ev1 :: t1 = ev2 :: nil.
Proof.
  intros.
  assert (t1 = nil). exploit assign_loc_trace; eauto. destruct t1; simpl; tauto.
  inv H. eapply volatile_store_receptive; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma semantics_strongly_receptive:
  forall p, strongly_receptive (semantics p).
Proof.
  intros. constructor; simpl; intros.
(* receptiveness *)
  set (ge := globalenv p) in *.
  inversion H; subst.
  inv H1.
  (* valof volatile *)
  exploit deref_loc_receptive; eauto. intros [A [v' B]].
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_rvalof_volatile; eauto.
  (* assign *)
  exploit assign_loc_receptive; eauto. intro EQ; rewrite EQ in H.
  econstructor; econstructor; eauto.
  (* assignop *)
  destruct t0 as [ | ev0 t0]; simpl in H10.
  subst t2. exploit assign_loc_receptive; eauto. intros EQ; rewrite EQ in H.
  econstructor; econstructor; eauto.
  inv H10. exploit deref_loc_receptive; eauto. intros [EQ [v1' A]]. subst t0.
  destruct (sem_binary_operation ge op v1' (typeof l) v2 (typeof r) m) as [v3'|] eqn:?.
  destruct (sem_cast v3' tyres (typeof l) m) as [v4'|] eqn:?.
  destruct (classic (exists t2' m'' v'', assign_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf v4' t2' m'' v'')).
  destruct H1 as [t2' [m'' [v'' P]]].
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_assignop with (v1 := v1'); eauto. simpl; reflexivity.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_assignop_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; rewrite Heqo0. intros; red; intros; elim H1. exists t0, m'0, v'0; auto.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_assignop_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; rewrite Heqo0; auto.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_assignop_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; auto.
  (* assignop stuck *)
  exploit deref_loc_receptive; eauto. intros [EQ [v1' A]]. subst t1.
  destruct (sem_binary_operation ge op v1' (typeof l) v2 (typeof r) m) as [v3'|] eqn:?.
  destruct (sem_cast v3' tyres (typeof l) m) as [v4'|] eqn:?.
  destruct (classic (exists t2' m'' v'', assign_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf v4' t2' m'' v'')).
  destruct H1 as [t2' [m'' [v'' P]]].
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_assignop with (v1 := v1'); eauto. simpl; reflexivity.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_assignop_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; rewrite Heqo0. intros; red; intros; elim H1. exists t2, m', v'; auto.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_assignop_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; rewrite Heqo0; auto.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_assignop_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; auto.
  (* postincr *)
  destruct t0 as [ | ev0 t0]; simpl in H9.
  subst t2. exploit assign_loc_receptive; eauto. intros EQ; rewrite EQ in H.
  econstructor; econstructor; eauto.
  inv H9. exploit deref_loc_receptive; eauto. intros [EQ [v1' A]]. subst t0.
  destruct (sem_incrdecr ge id v1' (typeof l) m) as [v2'|] eqn:?.
  destruct (sem_cast v2' (incrdecr_type (typeof l)) (typeof l) m) as [v3'|] eqn:?.
  destruct (classic (exists t2' m'' v'', assign_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf v3' t2' m'' v'')).
  destruct H1 as [t2' [m'' [v'' P]]].
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_postincr with (v1 := v1'); eauto. simpl; reflexivity.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_postincr_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; rewrite Heqo0. intros; red; intros; elim H1. exists t0, m'0, v'0; auto.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_postincr_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; rewrite Heqo0; auto.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_postincr_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; auto.
  (* postincr stuck *)
  exploit deref_loc_receptive; eauto. intros [EQ [v1' A]]. subst t1.
  destruct (sem_incrdecr ge id v1' (typeof l) m) as [v2'|] eqn:?.
  destruct (sem_cast v2' (incrdecr_type (typeof l)) (typeof l) m) as [v3'|] eqn:?.
  destruct (classic (exists t2' m'' v'', assign_loc ge (typeof l) m b ofs bf v3' t2' m'' v'')).
  destruct H1 as [t2' [m'' [v'' P]]].
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_postincr with (v1 := v1'); eauto. simpl; reflexivity.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_postincr_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; rewrite Heqo0. intros; red; intros; elim H1. exists t2, m', v'; auto.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_postincr_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; rewrite Heqo0; auto.
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_postincr_stuck with (v1 := v1'); eauto.
  rewrite Heqo; auto.
  (* builtin *)
  exploit external_call_trace_length; eauto. destruct t1; simpl; intros.
  exploit external_call_receptive; eauto. intros [vres2 [m2 EC2]].
  econstructor; econstructor. left; eapply step_builtin; eauto.
  extlia.
  (* external calls *)
  inv H1.
  exploit external_call_trace_length; eauto. destruct t1; simpl; intros.
  exploit external_call_receptive; eauto. intros [vres2 [m2 EC2]].
  exists (Returnstate vres2 k m2); exists E0; right; econstructor; eauto.
  extlia.
(* well-behaved traces *)
  red; intros. inv H; inv H0; simpl; auto.
  (* valof volatile *)
  exploit deref_loc_trace; eauto. destruct t; auto. destruct t; tauto.
  (* assign *)
  exploit assign_loc_trace; eauto. destruct t; auto. destruct t; simpl; tauto.
  (* assignop *)
  exploit deref_loc_trace; eauto. exploit assign_loc_trace; eauto.
  destruct t1. destruct t2. simpl; auto. destruct t2; simpl; tauto.
  destruct t1. destruct t2. simpl; auto. destruct t2; simpl; tauto.
  tauto.
  (* assignop stuck *)
  exploit deref_loc_trace; eauto. destruct t; auto. destruct t; tauto.
  (* postincr *)
  exploit deref_loc_trace; eauto. exploit assign_loc_trace; eauto.
  destruct t1. destruct t2. simpl; auto. destruct t2; simpl; tauto.
  destruct t1. destruct t2. simpl; auto. destruct t2; simpl; tauto.
  tauto.
  (* postincr stuck *)
  exploit deref_loc_trace; eauto. destruct t; auto. destruct t; tauto.
  (* builtins *)
  exploit external_call_trace_length; eauto.
  destruct t; simpl; auto. destruct t; simpl; auto. intros; extlia.
  (* external calls *)
  exploit external_call_trace_length; eauto.
  destruct t; simpl; auto. destruct t; simpl; auto. intros; extlia.
Qed.

The main simulation result.

Theorem strategy_simulation:
  forall p, backward_simulation (Csem.semantics p) (semantics p).
Proof.
  intros.
  apply backward_simulation_plus with (match_states := fun (S1 S2: state) => S1 = S2); simpl.
(* symbols *)
  auto.
(* initial states exist *)
  intros. exists s1; auto.
(* initial states match *)
  intros. exists s2; auto.
(* final states match *)
  intros. subst s2. auto.
(* progress *)
  intros. subst s2. apply progress. auto.
(* simulation *)
  intros. subst s1. exists s2'; split; auto. apply step_simulation; auto.
Qed.

A big-step semantics for CompCert C implementing the reduction strategy.


Section BIGSTEP.

Variable ge: genv.

The execution of a statement produces an ``outcome'', indicating how the execution terminated: either normally or prematurely through the execution of a break, continue or return statement.

Inductive outcome: Type :=
   | Out_break: outcome (* terminated by break *)
   | Out_continue: outcome (* terminated by continue *)
   | Out_normal: outcome (* terminated normally *)
   | Out_return: option (val * type) -> outcome. (* terminated by return *)

Inductive out_normal_or_continue : outcome -> Prop :=
  | Out_normal_or_continue_N: out_normal_or_continue Out_normal
  | Out_normal_or_continue_C: out_normal_or_continue Out_continue.

Inductive out_break_or_return : outcome -> outcome -> Prop :=
  | Out_break_or_return_B: out_break_or_return Out_break Out_normal
  | Out_break_or_return_R: forall ov,
      out_break_or_return (Out_return ov) (Out_return ov).

Definition outcome_switch (out: outcome) : outcome :=
  match out with
  | Out_break => Out_normal
  | o => o
  end.

Definition outcome_result_value (out: outcome) (t: type) (v: val) (m: mem) : Prop :=
  match out, t with
  | Out_normal, Tvoid => v = Vundef
  | Out_return None, Tvoid => v = Vundef
  | Out_return (Some (v', ty')), ty => ty <> Tvoid /\ sem_cast v' ty' ty m = Some v
  | _, _ => False
  end.

eval_expression ge e m1 a t m2 v describes the evaluation of the complex expression a. v is the resulting value, m2 the final memory state, and t the trace of input/output events performed during this evaluation.

Inductive eval_expression: env -> mem -> expr -> trace -> mem -> val -> Prop :=
  | eval_expression_intro: forall e m a t m' a' v,
      eval_expr e m RV a t m' a' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m' a' v ->
      eval_expression e m a t m' v

with eval_expr: env -> mem -> kind -> expr -> trace -> mem -> expr -> Prop :=
  | eval_val: forall e m v ty,
      eval_expr e m RV (Eval v ty) E0 m (Eval v ty)
  | eval_var: forall e m x ty,
      eval_expr e m LV (Evar x ty) E0 m (Evar x ty)
  | eval_field: forall e m a t m' a' f ty,
      eval_expr e m RV a t m' a' ->
      eval_expr e m LV (Efield a f ty) t m' (Efield a' f ty)
  | eval_valof: forall e m a t m' a' ty,
      type_is_volatile (typeof a) = false ->
      eval_expr e m LV a t m' a' ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Evalof a ty) t m' (Evalof a' ty)
  | eval_valof_volatile: forall e m a t1 m' a' ty b ofs bf t2 v,
      type_is_volatile (typeof a) = true ->
      eval_expr e m LV a t1 m' a' ->
      eval_simple_lvalue ge e m' a' b ofs bf ->
      deref_loc ge (typeof a) m' b ofs bf t2 v ->
      ty = typeof a ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Evalof a ty) (t1 ** t2) m' (Eval v ty)
  | eval_deref: forall e m a t m' a' ty,
      eval_expr e m RV a t m' a' ->
      eval_expr e m LV (Ederef a ty) t m' (Ederef a' ty)
  | eval_addrof: forall e m a t m' a' ty,
      eval_expr e m LV a t m' a' ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Eaddrof a ty) t m' (Eaddrof a' ty)
  | eval_unop: forall e m a t m' a' op ty,
      eval_expr e m RV a t m' a' ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Eunop op a ty) t m' (Eunop op a' ty)
  | eval_binop: forall e m a1 t1 m' a1' a2 t2 m'' a2' op ty,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> eval_expr e m' RV a2 t2 m'' a2' ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Ebinop op a1 a2 ty) (t1 ** t2) m'' (Ebinop op a1' a2' ty)
  | eval_cast: forall e m a t m' a' ty,
      eval_expr e m RV a t m' a' ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Ecast a ty) t m' (Ecast a' ty)
  | eval_seqand_true: forall e m a1 a2 ty t1 m' a1' v1 t2 m'' a2' v2 v,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m' a1' v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a1) m' = Some true ->
      eval_expr e m' RV a2 t2 m'' a2' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m'' a2' v2 ->
      sem_cast v2 (typeof a2) type_bool m'' = Some v ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Eseqand a1 a2 ty) (t1**t2) m'' (Eval v ty)
  | eval_seqand_false: forall e m a1 a2 ty t1 m' a1' v1,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m' a1' v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a1) m' = Some false ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Eseqand a1 a2 ty) t1 m' (Eval (Vint Int.zero) ty)
  | eval_seqor_false: forall e m a1 a2 ty t1 m' a1' v1 t2 m'' a2' v2 v,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m' a1' v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a1) m' = Some false ->
      eval_expr e m' RV a2 t2 m'' a2' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m'' a2' v2 ->
      sem_cast v2 (typeof a2) type_bool m'' = Some v ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Eseqor a1 a2 ty) (t1**t2) m'' (Eval v ty)
  | eval_seqor_true: forall e m a1 a2 ty t1 m' a1' v1,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m' a1' v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a1) m' = Some true ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Eseqor a1 a2 ty) t1 m' (Eval (Vint Int.one) ty)
  | eval_condition: forall e m a1 a2 a3 ty t1 m' a1' v1 t2 m'' a' v' b v,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m' a1' v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a1) m' = Some b ->
      eval_expr e m' RV (if b then a2 else a3) t2 m'' a' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m'' a' v' ->
      sem_cast v' (typeof (if b then a2 else a3)) ty m'' = Some v ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Econdition a1 a2 a3 ty) (t1**t2) m'' (Eval v ty)
  | eval_sizeof: forall e m ty' ty,
      eval_expr e m RV (Esizeof ty' ty) E0 m (Esizeof ty' ty)
  | eval_alignof: forall e m ty' ty,
      eval_expr e m RV (Ealignof ty' ty) E0 m (Ealignof ty' ty)
  | eval_assign: forall e m l r ty t1 m1 l' t2 m2 r' b ofs bf v v1 v' t3 m3,
      eval_expr e m LV l t1 m1 l' -> eval_expr e m1 RV r t2 m2 r' ->
      eval_simple_lvalue ge e m2 l' b ofs bf ->
      eval_simple_rvalue ge e m2 r' v ->
      sem_cast v (typeof r) (typeof l) m2 = Some v1 ->
      assign_loc ge (typeof l) m2 b ofs bf v1 t3 m3 v' ->
      ty = typeof l ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Eassign l r ty) (t1**t2**t3) m3 (Eval v' ty)
  | eval_assignop: forall e m op l r tyres ty t1 m1 l' t2 m2 r' b ofs bf
                          v1 v2 v3 v4 v' t3 t4 m3,
      eval_expr e m LV l t1 m1 l' -> eval_expr e m1 RV r t2 m2 r' ->
      eval_simple_lvalue ge e m2 l' b ofs bf ->
      deref_loc ge (typeof l) m2 b ofs bf t3 v1 ->
      eval_simple_rvalue ge e m2 r' v2 ->
      sem_binary_operation ge op v1 (typeof l) v2 (typeof r) m2 = Some v3 ->
      sem_cast v3 tyres (typeof l) m2 = Some v4 ->
      assign_loc ge (typeof l) m2 b ofs bf v4 t4 m3 v' ->
      ty = typeof l ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Eassignop op l r tyres ty) (t1**t2**t3**t4) m3 (Eval v' ty)
  | eval_postincr: forall e m id l ty t1 m1 l' b ofs bf v1 v2 v3 v' m2 t2 t3,
      eval_expr e m LV l t1 m1 l' ->
      eval_simple_lvalue ge e m1 l' b ofs bf ->
      deref_loc ge ty m1 b ofs bf t2 v1 ->
      sem_incrdecr ge id v1 ty m1 = Some v2 ->
      sem_cast v2 (incrdecr_type ty) ty m1 = Some v3 ->
      assign_loc ge ty m1 b ofs bf v3 t3 m2 v' ->
      ty = typeof l ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Epostincr id l ty) (t1**t2**t3) m2 (Eval v1 ty)
  | eval_comma: forall e m r1 r2 ty t1 m1 r1' v1 t2 m2 r2',
      eval_expr e m RV r1 t1 m1 r1' ->
      eval_simple_rvalue ge e m1 r1' v1 ->
      eval_expr e m1 RV r2 t2 m2 r2' ->
      ty = typeof r2 ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Ecomma r1 r2 ty) (t1**t2) m2 r2'
  | eval_call: forall e m rf rargs ty t1 m1 rf' t2 m2 rargs' vf vargs
                      targs tres cconv fd t3 m3 vres,
      eval_expr e m RV rf t1 m1 rf' -> eval_exprlist e m1 rargs t2 m2 rargs' ->
      eval_simple_rvalue ge e m2 rf' vf ->
      eval_simple_list ge e m2 rargs' targs vargs ->
      classify_fun (typeof rf) = fun_case_f targs tres cconv ->
      Genv.find_funct ge vf = Some fd ->
      type_of_fundef fd = Tfunction targs tres cconv ->
      eval_funcall m2 fd vargs t3 m3 vres ->
      eval_expr e m RV (Ecall rf rargs ty) (t1**t2**t3) m3 (Eval vres ty)

with eval_exprlist: env -> mem -> exprlist -> trace -> mem -> exprlist -> Prop :=
  | eval_nil: forall e m,
      eval_exprlist e m Enil E0 m Enil
  | eval_cons: forall e m a1 al t1 m1 a1' t2 m2 al',
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m1 a1' -> eval_exprlist e m1 al t2 m2 al' ->
      eval_exprlist e m (Econs a1 al) (t1**t2) m2 (Econs a1' al')

exec_stmt ge e m1 s t m2 out describes the execution of the statement s. out is the outcome for this execution. m1 is the initial memory state, m2 the final memory state. t is the trace of input/output events performed during this evaluation.

with exec_stmt: env -> mem -> statement -> trace -> mem -> outcome -> Prop :=
  | exec_Sskip: forall e m,
      exec_stmt e m Sskip
               E0 m Out_normal
  | exec_Sdo: forall e m a t m' v,
      eval_expression e m a t m' v ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sdo a)
                t m' Out_normal
  | exec_Sseq_1: forall e m s1 s2 t1 m1 t2 m2 out,
      exec_stmt e m s1 t1 m1 Out_normal ->
      exec_stmt e m1 s2 t2 m2 out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Ssequence s1 s2)
                (t1 ** t2) m2 out
  | exec_Sseq_2: forall e m s1 s2 t1 m1 out,
      exec_stmt e m s1 t1 m1 out ->
      out <> Out_normal ->
      exec_stmt e m (Ssequence s1 s2)
                t1 m1 out
  | exec_Sifthenelse: forall e m a s1 s2 t1 m1 v1 t2 m2 b out,
      eval_expression e m a t1 m1 v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a) m1 = Some b ->
      exec_stmt e m1 (if b then s1 else s2) t2 m2 out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sifthenelse a s1 s2)
                (t1**t2) m2 out
  | exec_Sreturn_none: forall e m,
      exec_stmt e m (Sreturn None)
               E0 m (Out_return None)
  | exec_Sreturn_some: forall e m a t m' v,
      eval_expression e m a t m' v ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sreturn (Some a))
                t m' (Out_return (Some(v, typeof a)))
  | exec_Sbreak: forall e m,
      exec_stmt e m Sbreak
               E0 m Out_break
  | exec_Scontinue: forall e m,
      exec_stmt e m Scontinue
               E0 m Out_continue
  | exec_Swhile_false: forall e m a s t m' v,
      eval_expression e m a t m' v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a) m' = Some false ->
      exec_stmt e m (Swhile a s)
                t m' Out_normal
  | exec_Swhile_stop: forall e m a s t1 m1 v t2 m2 out' out,
      eval_expression e m a t1 m1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a) m1 = Some true ->
      exec_stmt e m1 s t2 m2 out' ->
      out_break_or_return out' out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Swhile a s)
                (t1**t2) m2 out
  | exec_Swhile_loop: forall e m a s t1 m1 v t2 m2 out1 t3 m3 out,
      eval_expression e m a t1 m1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a) m1 = Some true ->
      exec_stmt e m1 s t2 m2 out1 ->
      out_normal_or_continue out1 ->
      exec_stmt e m2 (Swhile a s) t3 m3 out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Swhile a s)
                (t1 ** t2 ** t3) m3 out
  | exec_Sdowhile_false: forall e m s a t1 m1 out1 t2 m2 v,
      exec_stmt e m s t1 m1 out1 ->
      out_normal_or_continue out1 ->
      eval_expression e m1 a t2 m2 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a) m2 = Some false ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sdowhile a s)
                (t1 ** t2) m2 Out_normal
  | exec_Sdowhile_stop: forall e m s a t m1 out1 out,
      exec_stmt e m s t m1 out1 ->
      out_break_or_return out1 out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sdowhile a s)
                t m1 out
  | exec_Sdowhile_loop: forall e m s a t1 m1 out1 t2 m2 v t3 m3 out,
      exec_stmt e m s t1 m1 out1 ->
      out_normal_or_continue out1 ->
      eval_expression e m1 a t2 m2 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a) m2 = Some true ->
      exec_stmt e m2 (Sdowhile a s) t3 m3 out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sdowhile a s)
                (t1 ** t2 ** t3) m3 out
  | exec_Sfor_start: forall e m s a1 a2 a3 out m1 m2 t1 t2,
      exec_stmt e m a1 t1 m1 Out_normal ->
      exec_stmt e m1 (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s) t2 m2 out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sfor a1 a2 a3 s)
                (t1 ** t2) m2 out
  | exec_Sfor_false: forall e m s a2 a3 t m' v,
      eval_expression e m a2 t m' v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a2) m' = Some false ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s)
                t m' Out_normal
  | exec_Sfor_stop: forall e m s a2 a3 t1 m1 v t2 m2 out1 out,
      eval_expression e m a2 t1 m1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a2) m1 = Some true ->
      exec_stmt e m1 s t2 m2 out1 ->
      out_break_or_return out1 out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s)
                (t1 ** t2) m2 out
  | exec_Sfor_loop: forall e m s a2 a3 t1 m1 v t2 m2 out1 t3 m3 t4 m4 out,
      eval_expression e m a2 t1 m1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a2) m1 = Some true ->
      exec_stmt e m1 s t2 m2 out1 ->
      out_normal_or_continue out1 ->
      exec_stmt e m2 a3 t3 m3 Out_normal ->
      exec_stmt e m3 (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s) t4 m4 out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s)
                (t1 ** t2 ** t3 ** t4) m4 out
  | exec_Sswitch: forall e m a sl t1 m1 v n t2 m2 out,
      eval_expression e m a t1 m1 v ->
      sem_switch_arg v (typeof a) = Some n ->
      exec_stmt e m1 (seq_of_labeled_statement (select_switch n sl)) t2 m2 out ->
      exec_stmt e m (Sswitch a sl)
                (t1 ** t2) m2 (outcome_switch out)

eval_funcall m1 fd args t m2 res describes the invocation of function fd with arguments args. res is the value returned by the call.

with eval_funcall: mem -> fundef -> list val -> trace -> mem -> val -> Prop :=
  | eval_funcall_internal: forall m f vargs t e m1 m2 m3 out vres m4,
      list_norepet (var_names f.(fn_params) ++ var_names f.(fn_vars)) ->
      alloc_variables ge empty_env m (f.(fn_params) ++ f.(fn_vars)) e m1 ->
      bind_parameters ge e m1 f.(fn_params) vargs m2 ->
      exec_stmt e m2 f.(fn_body) t m3 out ->
      outcome_result_value out f.(fn_return) vres m3 ->
      Mem.free_list m3 (blocks_of_env ge e) = Some m4 ->
      eval_funcall m (Internal f) vargs t m4 vres
  | eval_funcall_external: forall m ef targs tres cconv vargs t vres m',
      external_call ef ge vargs m t vres m' ->
      eval_funcall m (External ef targs tres cconv) vargs t m' vres.

Scheme eval_expression_ind5 := Minimality for eval_expression Sort Prop
  with eval_expr_ind5 := Minimality for eval_expr Sort Prop
  with eval_exprlist_ind5 := Minimality for eval_exprlist Sort Prop
  with exec_stmt_ind5 := Minimality for exec_stmt Sort Prop
  with eval_funcall_ind5 := Minimality for eval_funcall Sort Prop.

Combined Scheme bigstep_induction from
        eval_expression_ind5, eval_expr_ind5, eval_exprlist_ind5,
        exec_stmt_ind5, eval_funcall_ind5.

evalinf_expr ge e m1 K a T denotes the fact that expression a diverges in initial state m1. T is the trace of input/output events performed during this evaluation.

CoInductive evalinf_expr: env -> mem -> kind -> expr -> traceinf -> Prop :=
  | evalinf_field: forall e m a t f ty,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a t ->
      evalinf_expr e m LV (Efield a f ty) t
  | evalinf_valof: forall e m a t ty,
      evalinf_expr e m LV a t ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Evalof a ty) t
  | evalinf_deref: forall e m a t ty,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a t ->
      evalinf_expr e m LV (Ederef a ty) t
  | evalinf_addrof: forall e m a t ty,
      evalinf_expr e m LV a t ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eaddrof a ty) t
  | evalinf_unop: forall e m a t op ty,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a t ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eunop op a ty) t
  | evalinf_binop_left: forall e m a1 t1 a2 op ty,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a1 t1 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Ebinop op a1 a2 ty) t1
  | evalinf_binop_right: forall e m a1 t1 m' a1' a2 t2 op ty,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> evalinf_expr e m' RV a2 t2 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Ebinop op a1 a2 ty) (t1 *** t2)
  | evalinf_cast: forall e m a t ty,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a t ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Ecast a ty) t
  | evalinf_seqand: forall e m a1 a2 ty t1,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a1 t1 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eseqand a1 a2 ty) t1
  | evalinf_seqand_2: forall e m a1 a2 ty t1 m' a1' v1 t2,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m' a1' v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a1) m' = Some true ->
      evalinf_expr e m' RV a2 t2 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eseqand a1 a2 ty) (t1***t2)
  | evalinf_seqor: forall e m a1 a2 ty t1,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a1 t1 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eseqor a1 a2 ty) t1
  | evalinf_seqor_2: forall e m a1 a2 ty t1 m' a1' v1 t2,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m' a1' v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a1) m' = Some false ->
      evalinf_expr e m' RV a2 t2 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eseqor a1 a2 ty) (t1***t2)
  | evalinf_condition: forall e m a1 a2 a3 ty t1,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a1 t1 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Econdition a1 a2 a3 ty) t1
  | evalinf_condition_2: forall e m a1 a2 a3 ty t1 m' a1' v1 t2 b,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m' a1' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m' a1' v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a1) m' = Some b ->
      evalinf_expr e m' RV (if b then a2 else a3) t2 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Econdition a1 a2 a3 ty) (t1***t2)
  | evalinf_assign_left: forall e m a1 t1 a2 ty,
      evalinf_expr e m LV a1 t1 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eassign a1 a2 ty) t1
  | evalinf_assign_right: forall e m a1 t1 m' a1' a2 t2 ty,
      eval_expr e m LV a1 t1 m' a1' -> evalinf_expr e m' RV a2 t2 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eassign a1 a2 ty) (t1 *** t2)
  | evalinf_assignop_left: forall e m a1 t1 a2 op tyres ty,
      evalinf_expr e m LV a1 t1 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eassignop op a1 a2 tyres ty) t1
  | evalinf_assignop_right: forall e m a1 t1 m' a1' a2 t2 op tyres ty,
      eval_expr e m LV a1 t1 m' a1' -> evalinf_expr e m' RV a2 t2 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Eassignop op a1 a2 tyres ty) (t1 *** t2)
  | evalinf_postincr: forall e m a t id ty,
      evalinf_expr e m LV a t ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Epostincr id a ty) t
  | evalinf_comma_left: forall e m a1 t1 a2 ty,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a1 t1 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Ecomma a1 a2 ty) t1
  | evalinf_comma_right: forall e m a1 t1 m1 a1' v1 a2 t2 ty,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m1 a1' -> eval_simple_rvalue ge e m1 a1' v1 ->
      ty = typeof a2 ->
      evalinf_expr e m1 RV a2 t2 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Ecomma a1 a2 ty) (t1 *** t2)
  | evalinf_call_left: forall e m a1 t1 a2 ty,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a1 t1 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Ecall a1 a2 ty) t1
  | evalinf_call_right: forall e m a1 t1 m1 a1' a2 t2 ty,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m1 a1' ->
      evalinf_exprlist e m1 a2 t2 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Ecall a1 a2 ty) (t1 *** t2)
  | evalinf_call: forall e m rf rargs ty t1 m1 rf' t2 m2 rargs' vf vargs
                      targs tres cconv fd t3,
      eval_expr e m RV rf t1 m1 rf' -> eval_exprlist e m1 rargs t2 m2 rargs' ->
      eval_simple_rvalue ge e m2 rf' vf ->
      eval_simple_list ge e m2 rargs' targs vargs ->
      classify_fun (typeof rf) = fun_case_f targs tres cconv ->
      Genv.find_funct ge vf = Some fd ->
      type_of_fundef fd = Tfunction targs tres cconv ->
      evalinf_funcall m2 fd vargs t3 ->
      evalinf_expr e m RV (Ecall rf rargs ty) (t1***t2***t3)

with evalinf_exprlist: env -> mem -> exprlist -> traceinf -> Prop :=
  | evalinf_cons_left: forall e m a1 al t1,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a1 t1 ->
      evalinf_exprlist e m (Econs a1 al) t1
  | evalinf_cons_right: forall e m a1 al t1 m1 a1' t2,
      eval_expr e m RV a1 t1 m1 a1' -> evalinf_exprlist e m1 al t2 ->
      evalinf_exprlist e m (Econs a1 al) (t1***t2)

execinf_stmt ge e m1 s t describes the diverging execution of the statement s.

with execinf_stmt: env -> mem -> statement -> traceinf -> Prop :=
  | execinf_Sdo: forall e m a t,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a t ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sdo a) t
  | execinf_Sseq_1: forall e m s1 s2 t1,
      execinf_stmt e m s1 t1 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Ssequence s1 s2) t1
  | execinf_Sseq_2: forall e m s1 s2 t1 m1 t2,
      exec_stmt e m s1 t1 m1 Out_normal ->
      execinf_stmt e m1 s2 t2 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Ssequence s1 s2) (t1***t2)
  | execinf_Sifthenelse_test: forall e m a s1 s2 t1,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a t1 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sifthenelse a s1 s2) t1
  | execinf_Sifthenelse: forall e m a s1 s2 t1 m1 v1 t2 b,
      eval_expression e m a t1 m1 v1 ->
      bool_val v1 (typeof a) m1 = Some b ->
      execinf_stmt e m1 (if b then s1 else s2) t2 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sifthenelse a s1 s2) (t1***t2)
  | execinf_Sreturn_some: forall e m a t,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a t ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sreturn (Some a)) t
  | execinf_Swhile_test: forall e m a s t1,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a t1 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Swhile a s) t1
  | execinf_Swhile_body: forall e m a s t1 m1 v t2,
      eval_expression e m a t1 m1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a) m1 = Some true ->
      execinf_stmt e m1 s t2 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Swhile a s) (t1***t2)
  | execinf_Swhile_loop: forall e m a s t1 m1 v t2 m2 out1 t3,
      eval_expression e m a t1 m1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a) m1 = Some true ->
      exec_stmt e m1 s t2 m2 out1 ->
      out_normal_or_continue out1 ->
      execinf_stmt e m2 (Swhile a s) t3 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Swhile a s) (t1***t2***t3)
  | execinf_Sdowhile_body: forall e m s a t1,
      execinf_stmt e m s t1 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sdowhile a s) t1
  | execinf_Sdowhile_test: forall e m s a t1 m1 out1 t2,
      exec_stmt e m s t1 m1 out1 ->
      out_normal_or_continue out1 ->
      evalinf_expr e m1 RV a t2 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sdowhile a s) (t1***t2)
  | execinf_Sdowhile_loop: forall e m s a t1 m1 out1 t2 m2 v t3,
      exec_stmt e m s t1 m1 out1 ->
      out_normal_or_continue out1 ->
      eval_expression e m1 a t2 m2 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a) m2 = Some true ->
      execinf_stmt e m2 (Sdowhile a s) t3 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sdowhile a s) (t1***t2***t3)
  | execinf_Sfor_start_1: forall e m s a1 a2 a3 t1,
      execinf_stmt e m a1 t1 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sfor a1 a2 a3 s) t1
  | execinf_Sfor_start_2: forall e m s a1 a2 a3 m1 t1 t2,
      exec_stmt e m a1 t1 m1 Out_normal -> a1 <> Sskip ->
      execinf_stmt e m1 (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s) t2 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sfor a1 a2 a3 s) (t1***t2)
  | execinf_Sfor_test: forall e m s a2 a3 t,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a2 t ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s) t
  | execinf_Sfor_body: forall e m s a2 a3 t1 m1 v t2,
      eval_expression e m a2 t1 m1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a2) m1 = Some true ->
      execinf_stmt e m1 s t2 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s) (t1***t2)
  | execinf_Sfor_next: forall e m s a2 a3 t1 m1 v t2 m2 out1 t3,
      eval_expression e m a2 t1 m1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a2) m1 = Some true ->
      exec_stmt e m1 s t2 m2 out1 ->
      out_normal_or_continue out1 ->
      execinf_stmt e m2 a3 t3 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s) (t1***t2***t3)
  | execinf_Sfor_loop: forall e m s a2 a3 t1 m1 v t2 m2 out1 t3 m3 t4,
      eval_expression e m a2 t1 m1 v ->
      bool_val v (typeof a2) m1 = Some true ->
      exec_stmt e m1 s t2 m2 out1 ->
      out_normal_or_continue out1 ->
      exec_stmt e m2 a3 t3 m3 Out_normal ->
      execinf_stmt e m3 (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s) t4 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s) (t1***t2***t3***t4)
  | execinf_Sswitch_expr: forall e m a sl t1,
      evalinf_expr e m RV a t1 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sswitch a sl) t1
  | execinf_Sswitch_body: forall e m a sl t1 m1 v n t2,
      eval_expression e m a t1 m1 v ->
      sem_switch_arg v (typeof a) = Some n ->
      execinf_stmt e m1 (seq_of_labeled_statement (select_switch n sl)) t2 ->
      execinf_stmt e m (Sswitch a sl) (t1***t2)

evalinf_funcall m1 fd args t m2 res describes a diverging invocation of function fd with arguments args.

with evalinf_funcall: mem -> fundef -> list val -> traceinf -> Prop :=
  | evalinf_funcall_internal: forall m f vargs t e m1 m2,
      list_norepet (var_names f.(fn_params) ++ var_names f.(fn_vars)) ->
      alloc_variables ge empty_env m (f.(fn_params) ++ f.(fn_vars)) e m1 ->
      bind_parameters ge e m1 f.(fn_params) vargs m2 ->
      execinf_stmt e m2 f.(fn_body) t ->
      evalinf_funcall m (Internal f) vargs t.

Implication from big-step semantics to transition semantics


Inductive outcome_state_match
       (e: env) (m: mem) (f: function) (k: cont): outcome -> state -> Prop :=
  | osm_normal:
      outcome_state_match e m f k Out_normal (State f Sskip k e m)
  | osm_break:
      outcome_state_match e m f k Out_break (State f Sbreak k e m)
  | osm_continue:
      outcome_state_match e m f k Out_continue (State f Scontinue k e m)
  | osm_return_none: forall k',
      call_cont k' = call_cont k ->
      outcome_state_match e m f k
        (Out_return None) (State f (Sreturn None) k' e m)
  | osm_return_some: forall v ty k',
      call_cont k' = call_cont k ->
      outcome_state_match e m f k
        (Out_return (Some (v, ty))) (ExprState f (Eval v ty) (Kreturn k') e m).

Lemma is_call_cont_call_cont:
  forall k, is_call_cont k -> call_cont k = k.
Proof.
  destruct k; simpl; intros; contradiction || auto.
Qed.

Lemma leftcontext_compose:
  forall k2 k3 C2, leftcontext k2 k3 C2 ->
  forall k1 C1, leftcontext k1 k2 C1 ->
  leftcontext k1 k3 (fun x => C2(C1 x))
with leftcontextlist_compose:
  forall k2 C2, leftcontextlist k2 C2 ->
  forall k1 C1, leftcontext k1 k2 C1 ->
  leftcontextlist k1 (fun x => C2(C1 x)).
Proof.
  induction 1; intros; try (constructor; eauto).
  replace (fun x => C1 x) with C1. auto. apply extensionality; auto.
  induction 1; intros; constructor; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma exprlist_app_leftcontext:
  forall rl1 rl2,
  simplelist rl1 = true -> leftcontextlist RV (fun x => exprlist_app rl1 (Econs x rl2)).
Proof.
  induction rl1; simpl; intros.
  apply lctx_list_head. constructor.
  destruct (andb_prop _ _ H). apply lctx_list_tail. auto. auto.
Qed.

Lemma exprlist_app_simple:
  forall rl1 rl2,
  simplelist (exprlist_app rl1 rl2) = simplelist rl1 && simplelist rl2.
Proof.
  induction rl1; intros; simpl. auto. rewrite IHrl1. apply andb_assoc.
Qed.

Lemma bigstep_to_steps:
  (forall e m a t m' v,
   eval_expression e m a t m' v ->
   forall f k,
   star step ge (ExprState f a k e m) t (ExprState f (Eval v (typeof a)) k e m'))
/\(forall e m K a t m' a',
   eval_expr e m K a t m' a' ->
   forall C f k, leftcontext K RV C ->
   simple a' = true /\ typeof a' = typeof a /\
   star step ge (ExprState f (C a) k e m) t (ExprState f (C a') k e m'))
/\(forall e m al t m' al',
   eval_exprlist e m al t m' al' ->
   forall a1 al2 ty C f k, leftcontext RV RV C -> simple a1 = true -> simplelist al2 = true ->
   simplelist al' = true /\
   star step ge (ExprState f (C (Ecall a1 (exprlist_app al2 al) ty)) k e m)
              t (ExprState f (C (Ecall a1 (exprlist_app al2 al') ty)) k e m'))
/\(forall e m s t m' out,
   exec_stmt e m s t m' out ->
   forall f k,
   exists S,
   star step ge (State f s k e m) t S /\ outcome_state_match e m' f k out S)
/\(forall m fd args t m' res,
   eval_funcall m fd args t m' res ->
   forall k,
   is_call_cont k ->
   star step ge (Callstate fd args k m) t (Returnstate res k m')).
Proof.
  apply bigstep_induction; intros.
(* expression, general *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => x) f k). constructor. intros [A [B C]].
  assert (match a' with Eval _ _ => False | _ => True end ->
          star step ge (ExprState f a k e m) t (ExprState f (Eval v (typeof a)) k e m')).
   intro. eapply star_right. eauto. left. eapply step_expr; eauto. traceEq.
  destruct a'; auto.
  simpl in B. rewrite B in C. inv H1. auto.

(* val *)
  simpl; intuition. apply star_refl.
(* var *)
  simpl; intuition. apply star_refl.
(* field *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Efield x f ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition; eauto.
(* valof *)
  exploit (H1 (fun x => C(Evalof x ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition; eauto. rewrite A; rewrite B; rewrite H; auto.
(* valof volatile *)
  exploit (H1 (fun x => C(Evalof x ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition.
  eapply star_right. eexact D.
  left. eapply step_rvalof_volatile; eauto. rewrite H4; eauto. congruence. congruence.
  traceEq.
(* deref *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Ederef x ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition; eauto.
(* addrof *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Eaddrof x ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition; eauto.
(* unop *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Eunop op x ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition; eauto.
(* binop *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Ebinop op x a2 ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  exploit (H2 (fun x => C(Ebinop op a1' x ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. auto. intros [E [F G]].
  simpl; intuition. eapply star_trans; eauto.
(* cast *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Ecast x ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition; eauto.
(* seqand true *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Eseqand x a2 ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  exploit (H4 (fun x => C(Eparen x type_bool ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [E [F G]].
  simpl; intuition. eapply star_trans. eexact D.
  eapply star_left. left; eapply step_seqand_true; eauto. rewrite B; auto.
  eapply star_right. eexact G.
  left; eapply step_paren; eauto. rewrite F; eauto.
  eauto. eauto. traceEq.
(* seqand false *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Eseqand x a2 ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition. eapply star_right. eexact D.
  left; eapply step_seqand_false; eauto. rewrite B; auto.
  traceEq.
(* seqor false *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Eseqor x a2 ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  exploit (H4 (fun x => C(Eparen x type_bool ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [E [F G]].
  simpl; intuition. eapply star_trans. eexact D.
  eapply star_left. left; eapply step_seqor_false; eauto. rewrite B; auto.
  eapply star_right. eexact G.
  left; eapply step_paren; eauto. rewrite F; eauto.
  eauto. eauto. traceEq.
(* seqor true *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Eseqor x a2 ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition. eapply star_right. eexact D.
  left; eapply step_seqor_true; eauto. rewrite B; auto.
  traceEq.
(* condition *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Econdition x a2 a3 ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  exploit (H4 (fun x => C(Eparen x ty ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [E [F G]].
  simpl. split; auto. split; auto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact D.
  eapply star_left. left; eapply step_condition; eauto. rewrite B; eauto.
  eapply star_right. eexact G. left; eapply step_paren; eauto. congruence.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
(* sizeof *)
  simpl; intuition. apply star_refl.
(* alignof *)
  simpl; intuition. apply star_refl.
(* assign *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Eassign x r ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  exploit (H2 (fun x => C(Eassign l' x ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. auto. intros [E [F G]].
  simpl; intuition.
  eapply star_trans. eexact D.
  eapply star_right. eexact G.
  left. eapply step_assign with (v1 := v1); eauto. congruence. rewrite B; eauto. congruence.
  reflexivity. traceEq.
(* assignop *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Eassignop op x r tyres ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  exploit (H2 (fun x => C(Eassignop op l' x tyres ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. auto. intros [E [F G]].
  simpl; intuition.
  eapply star_trans. eexact D.
  eapply star_right. eexact G.
  left. eapply step_assignop; eauto.
  rewrite B; eauto. rewrite B; rewrite F; eauto. rewrite B; eauto. rewrite B; eauto. congruence.
  reflexivity. traceEq.
(* postincr *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Epostincr id x ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  simpl; intuition.
  eapply star_right. eexact D.
  left. eapply step_postincr; eauto. congruence.
  traceEq.
(* comma *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Ecomma x r2 ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  exploit (H3 C). auto. intros [E [F G]].
  simpl; intuition. congruence.
  eapply star_trans. eexact D.
  eapply star_left. left; eapply step_comma; eauto.
  eexact G.
  reflexivity. traceEq.
(* call *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Ecall x rargs ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. intros [A [B D]].
  exploit (H2 rf' Enil ty C); eauto. intros [E F].
  simpl; intuition.
  eapply star_trans. eexact D.
  eapply star_trans. eexact F.
  eapply star_left. left; eapply step_call; eauto. congruence.
  eapply star_right. eapply H9. red; auto.
  right; constructor.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
(* nil *)
  simpl; intuition. apply star_refl.
(* cons *)
  exploit (H0 (fun x => C(Ecall a0 (exprlist_app al2 (Econs x al)) ty))).
    eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. auto.
    apply exprlist_app_leftcontext; auto. intros [A [B D]].
  exploit (H2 a0 (exprlist_app al2 (Econs a1' Enil))); eauto.
  rewrite exprlist_app_simple. simpl. rewrite H5; rewrite A; auto.
  repeat rewrite exprlist_app_assoc. simpl.
  intros [E F].
  simpl; intuition.
  eapply star_trans; eauto.

(* skip *)
  econstructor; split. apply star_refl. constructor.

(* do *)
  econstructor; split.
  eapply star_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_right. apply H0. right; constructor.
  reflexivity. traceEq.
  constructor.

(* sequence 2 *)
  destruct (H0 f (Kseq s2 k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto. inv B1.
  destruct (H2 f k) as [S2 [A2 B2]]; auto.
  econstructor; split.
  eapply star_left. right; econstructor.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  eapply star_left. right; constructor. eexact A2.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  auto.

(* sequence 1 *)
  destruct (H0 f (Kseq s2 k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto.
  set (S2 :=
    match out with
    | Out_break => State f Sbreak k e m1
    | Out_continue => State f Scontinue k e m1
    | _ => S1
    end).
  exists S2; split.
  eapply star_left. right; econstructor.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  unfold S2; inv B1.
    congruence.
    apply star_one. right; apply step_break_seq.
    apply star_one. right; apply step_continue_seq.
    apply star_refl.
    apply star_refl.
  reflexivity. traceEq.
  unfold S2; inv B1; congruence || econstructor; eauto.

(* ifthenelse *)
  destruct (H3 f k) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto.
  exists S1; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_ifthenelse_1.
  eapply star_trans. eapply H0.
  eapply star_left. 2: eexact A1. right; eapply step_ifthenelse_2; eauto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  auto.

(* return none *)
  econstructor; split. apply star_refl. constructor. auto.

(* return some *)
  econstructor; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_return_1.
  eapply H0. traceEq.
  econstructor; eauto.

(* break *)
  econstructor; split. apply star_refl. constructor.

(* continue *)
  econstructor; split. apply star_refl. constructor.

(* while false *)
  econstructor; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_while.
  eapply star_right. apply H0. right; eapply step_while_false; eauto.
  reflexivity. traceEq.
  constructor.

(* while stop *)
  destruct (H3 f (Kwhile2 a s k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]].
  set (S2 :=
    match out' with
    | Out_break => State f Sskip k e m2
    | _ => S1
    end).
  exists S2; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_while.
  eapply star_trans. apply H0.
  eapply star_left. right; eapply step_while_true; eauto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  unfold S2. inversion H4; subst.
  inv B1. apply star_one. right; constructor.
  apply star_refl.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  unfold S2. inversion H4; subst. constructor. inv B1; econstructor; eauto.

(* while loop *)
  destruct (H3 f (Kwhile2 a s k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]].
  destruct (H6 f k) as [S2 [A2 B2]]; auto.
  exists S2; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_while.
  eapply star_trans. apply H0.
  eapply star_left. right; eapply step_while_true; eauto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  eapply star_left.
  inv H4; inv B1; right; apply step_skip_or_continue_while; auto.
  eexact A2.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  auto.

(* dowhile false *)
  destruct (H0 f (Kdowhile1 a s k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]].
  exists (State f Sskip k e m2); split.
  eapply star_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  eapply star_left.
  inv H1; inv B1; right; eapply step_skip_or_continue_dowhile; eauto.
  eapply star_right. apply H3.
  right; eapply step_dowhile_false; eauto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  constructor.

(* dowhile stop *)
  destruct (H0 f (Kdowhile1 a s k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]].
  set (S2 :=
    match out1 with
    | Out_break => State f Sskip k e m1
    | _ => S1
    end).
  exists S2; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_dowhile.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  unfold S2. inversion H1; subst.
  inv B1. apply star_one. right; constructor.
  apply star_refl.
  reflexivity. traceEq.
  unfold S2. inversion H1; subst. constructor. inv B1; econstructor; eauto.

(* dowhile loop *)
  destruct (H0 f (Kdowhile1 a s k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]].
  destruct (H6 f k) as [S2 [A2 B2]]; auto.
  exists S2; split.
  eapply star_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  eapply star_left.
  inv H1; inv B1; right; eapply step_skip_or_continue_dowhile; eauto.
  eapply star_trans. apply H3.
  eapply star_left. right; eapply step_dowhile_true; eauto.
  eexact A2.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  auto.

(* for start *)
  assert (a1 = Sskip \/ a1 <> Sskip). destruct a1; auto; right; congruence.
  destruct H3.
  subst a1. inv H. apply H2; auto.
  destruct (H0 f (Kseq (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s) k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto. inv B1.
  destruct (H2 f k) as [S2 [A2 B2]]; auto.
  exists S2; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_for_start; auto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  eapply star_left. right; constructor. eexact A2.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  auto.

(* for false *)
  econstructor; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_for.
  eapply star_right. apply H0. right; eapply step_for_false; eauto.
  reflexivity. traceEq.
  constructor.

(* for stop *)
  destruct (H3 f (Kfor3 a2 a3 s k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]].
  set (S2 :=
    match out1 with
    | Out_break => State f Sskip k e m2
    | _ => S1
    end).
  exists S2; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_for.
  eapply star_trans. apply H0.
  eapply star_left. right; eapply step_for_true; eauto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  unfold S2. inversion H4; subst.
  inv B1. apply star_one. right; constructor.
  apply star_refl.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  unfold S2. inversion H4; subst. constructor. inv B1; econstructor; eauto.

(* for loop *)
  destruct (H3 f (Kfor3 a2 a3 s k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]].
  destruct (H6 f (Kfor4 a2 a3 s k)) as [S2 [A2 B2]]; auto. inv B2.
  destruct (H8 f k) as [S3 [A3 B3]]; auto.
  exists S3; split.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_for.
  eapply star_trans. apply H0.
  eapply star_left. right; eapply step_for_true; eauto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  eapply star_trans with (s2 := State f a3 (Kfor4 a2 a3 s k) e m2).
  inv H4; inv B1.
  apply star_one. right; constructor; auto.
  apply star_one. right; constructor; auto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A2.
  eapply star_left. right; constructor.
  eexact A3.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  auto.

(* switch *)
  destruct (H3 f (Kswitch2 k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]].
  set (S2 :=
    match out with
    | Out_normal => State f Sskip k e m2
    | Out_break => State f Sskip k e m2
    | Out_continue => State f Scontinue k e m2
    | _ => S1
    end).
  exists S2; split.
  eapply star_left. right; eapply step_switch.
  eapply star_trans. apply H0.
  eapply star_left. right; eapply step_expr_switch. eauto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  unfold S2; inv B1.
    apply star_one. right; constructor. auto.
    apply star_one. right; constructor. auto.
    apply star_one. right; constructor.
    apply star_refl.
    apply star_refl.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. traceEq.
  unfold S2. inv B1; simpl; econstructor; eauto.

(* call internal *)
  destruct (H3 f k) as [S1 [A1 B1]].
  eapply star_left. right; eapply step_internal_function; eauto.
  eapply star_right. eexact A1.
  inv B1; simpl in H4; try contradiction.
  (* Out_normal *)
  assert (fn_return f = Tvoid /\ vres = Vundef).
    destruct (fn_return f); auto || contradiction.
  destruct H7 as [P Q]. subst vres. right; eapply step_skip_call; eauto.
  (* Out_return None *)
  assert (fn_return f = Tvoid /\ vres = Vundef).
    destruct (fn_return f); auto || contradiction.
  destruct H8 as [P Q]. subst vres.
  rewrite <- (is_call_cont_call_cont k H6). rewrite <- H7.
  right; apply step_return_0; auto.
  (* Out_return Some *)
  destruct H4. rewrite <- (is_call_cont_call_cont k H6). rewrite <- H7.
  right; eapply step_return_2; eauto.
  reflexivity. traceEq.

(* call external *)
  apply star_one. right; apply step_external_function; auto.
Qed.

Lemma eval_expression_to_steps:
   forall e m a t m' v,
   eval_expression e m a t m' v ->
   forall f k,
   star step ge (ExprState f a k e m) t (ExprState f (Eval v (typeof a)) k e m').
Proof (proj1 bigstep_to_steps).

Lemma eval_expr_to_steps:
   forall e m K a t m' a',
   eval_expr e m K a t m' a' ->
   forall C f k, leftcontext K RV C ->
   simple a' = true /\ typeof a' = typeof a /\
   star step ge (ExprState f (C a) k e m) t (ExprState f (C a') k e m').
Proof (proj1 (proj2 bigstep_to_steps)).

Lemma eval_exprlist_to_steps:
   forall e m al t m' al',
   eval_exprlist e m al t m' al' ->
   forall a1 al2 ty C f k, leftcontext RV RV C -> simple a1 = true -> simplelist al2 = true ->
   simplelist al' = true /\
   star step ge (ExprState f (C (Ecall a1 (exprlist_app al2 al) ty)) k e m)
              t (ExprState f (C (Ecall a1 (exprlist_app al2 al') ty)) k e m').
Proof (proj1 (proj2 (proj2 bigstep_to_steps))).

Lemma exec_stmt_to_steps:
   forall e m s t m' out,
   exec_stmt e m s t m' out ->
   forall f k,
   exists S,
   star step ge (State f s k e m) t S /\ outcome_state_match e m' f k out S.
Proof (proj1 (proj2 (proj2 (proj2 bigstep_to_steps)))).

Lemma eval_funcall_to_steps:
  forall m fd args t m' res,
  eval_funcall m fd args t m' res ->
  forall k,
  is_call_cont k ->
  star step ge (Callstate fd args k m) t (Returnstate res k m').
Proof (proj2 (proj2 (proj2 (proj2 bigstep_to_steps)))).

Fixpoint esize (a: expr) : nat :=
  match a with
  | Eloc _ _ _ _ => 1%nat
  | Evar _ _ => 1%nat
  | Ederef r1 _ => S(esize r1)
  | Efield l1 _ _ => S(esize l1)
  | Eval _ _ => O
  | Evalof l1 _ => S(esize l1)
  | Eaddrof l1 _ => S(esize l1)
  | Eunop _ r1 _ => S(esize r1)
  | Ebinop _ r1 r2 _ => S(esize r1 + esize r2)%nat
  | Ecast r1 _ => S(esize r1)
  | Eseqand r1 r2 _ => S(esize r1)
  | Eseqor r1 r2 _ => S(esize r1)
  | Econdition r1 _ _ _ => S(esize r1)
  | Esizeof _ _ => 1%nat
  | Ealignof _ _ => 1%nat
  | Eassign l1 r2 _ => S(esize l1 + esize r2)%nat
  | Eassignop _ l1 r2 _ _ => S(esize l1 + esize r2)%nat
  | Epostincr _ l1 _ => S(esize l1)
  | Ecomma r1 r2 _ => S(esize r1 + esize r2)%nat
  | Ecall r1 rl2 _ => S(esize r1 + esizelist rl2)%nat
  | Ebuiltin ef tyargs rl _ => S(esizelist rl)
  | Eparen r1 _ _ => S(esize r1)
  end

with esizelist (el: exprlist) : nat :=
  match el with
  | Enil => O
  | Econs r1 rl2 => S(esize r1 + esizelist rl2)%nat
  end.

Lemma leftcontext_size:
  forall from to C,
  leftcontext from to C ->
  forall e1 e2,
  (esize e1 < esize e2)%nat ->
  (esize (C e1) < esize (C e2))%nat
with leftcontextlist_size:
  forall from C,
  leftcontextlist from C ->
  forall e1 e2,
  (esize e1 < esize e2)%nat ->
  (esizelist (C e1) < esizelist (C e2))%nat.
Proof.
  induction 1; intros; simpl; auto with arith.
  exploit leftcontextlist_size; eauto. auto with arith.
  exploit leftcontextlist_size; eauto. auto with arith.
  induction 1; intros; simpl; auto with arith.
  exploit leftcontext_size; eauto. auto with arith.
Qed.

Lemma evalinf_funcall_steps:
  forall m fd args t k,
  evalinf_funcall m fd args t ->
  forever_N step lt ge O (Callstate fd args k m) t.
Proof.
  cofix COF.

  assert (COS:
    forall e m s t f k,
    execinf_stmt e m s t ->
    forever_N step lt ge O (State f s k e m) t).
  cofix COS.

  assert (COE:
    forall e m K a t C f k,
    evalinf_expr e m K a t ->
    leftcontext K RV C ->
    forever_N step lt ge (esize a) (ExprState f (C a) k e m) t).
  cofix COE.

  assert (COEL:
    forall e m a t C f k a1 al ty,
    evalinf_exprlist e m a t ->
    leftcontext RV RV C -> simple a1 = true -> simplelist al = true ->
    forever_N step lt ge (esizelist a)
                   (ExprState f (C (Ecall a1 (exprlist_app al a) ty)) k e m) t).
  cofix COEL.
  intros. inv H.
(* cons left *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a0)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Ecall a1 (exprlist_app al (Econs x al0)) ty)).
  eauto. eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. constructor. auto.
  apply exprlist_app_leftcontext; auto. traceEq.
(* cons right *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H3
             (fun x => C(Ecall a1 (exprlist_app al (Econs x al0)) ty)) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. auto.
  apply exprlist_app_leftcontext; auto.
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esizelist al0)).
  eexact R. simpl; lia.
  change (Econs a1' al0) with (exprlist_app (Econs a1' Enil) al0).
  rewrite <- exprlist_app_assoc.
  eapply COEL. eauto. auto. auto.
  rewrite exprlist_app_simple. simpl. rewrite H2; rewrite P; auto.
  auto.

  intros. inv H.
(* field *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a0)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Efield x f0 ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* valof *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a0)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Evalof x ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* deref *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a0)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Ederef x ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* addrof *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a0)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Eaddrof x ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* unop *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a0)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Eunop op x ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* binop left *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a1)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Ebinop op x a2 ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* binop right *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H1 (fun x => C(Ebinop op x a2 ty)) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor.
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a2)). eexact R. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Ebinop op a1' x ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. auto. traceEq.
(* cast *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a0)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Ecast x ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* seqand left *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a1)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Eseqand x a2 ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* seqand 2 *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H1 (fun x => C(Eseqand x a2 ty)) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor.
  eapply forever_N_plus. eapply plus_right. eexact R.
  left; eapply step_seqand_true; eauto. rewrite Q; eauto.
  reflexivity.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => (C (Eparen x type_bool ty))). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* seqor left *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a1)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Eseqor x a2 ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* seqor 2 *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H1 (fun x => C(Eseqor x a2 ty)) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor.
  eapply forever_N_plus. eapply plus_right. eexact R.
  left; eapply step_seqor_false; eauto. rewrite Q; eauto.
  reflexivity.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => (C (Eparen x type_bool ty))). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* condition top *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a1)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Econdition x a2 a3 ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* condition *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H1 (fun x => C(Econdition x a2 a3 ty)) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor.
  eapply forever_N_plus. eapply plus_right. eexact R.
  left; eapply step_condition; eauto. rewrite Q; eauto.
  reflexivity.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => (C (Eparen x ty ty))). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* assign left *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a1)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Eassign x a2 ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* assign right *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H1 (fun x => C(Eassign x a2 ty)) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor.
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a2)). eexact R. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Eassign a1' x ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. auto. traceEq.
(* assignop left *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a1)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Eassignop op x a2 tyres ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* assignop right *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H1 (fun x => C(Eassignop op x a2 tyres ty)) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor.
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a2)). eexact R. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Eassignop op a1' x tyres ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. auto. traceEq.
(* postincr *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a0)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Epostincr id x ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* comma left *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a1)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Ecomma x a2 ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* comma right *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H1 (fun x => C(Ecomma x a2 (typeof a2))) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor.
  eapply forever_N_plus. eapply plus_right. eexact R.
  left; eapply step_comma; eauto. reflexivity.
  eapply COE with (C := C); eauto. traceEq.
(* call left *)
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esize a1)). apply star_refl. simpl; lia.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => C(Ecall x a2 ty)). eauto.
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor. traceEq.
(* call right *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H1 (fun x => C(Ecall x a2 ty)) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor.
  eapply forever_N_star with (a2 := (esizelist a2)). eexact R. simpl; lia.
  eapply COEL with (al := Enil). eauto. auto. auto. auto. traceEq.
(* call *)
  destruct (eval_expr_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H1 (fun x => C(Ecall x rargs ty)) f k)
  as [P [Q R]].
  eapply leftcontext_compose; eauto. repeat constructor.
  destruct (eval_exprlist_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ H2 rf' Enil ty C f k)
  as [S T]. auto. auto. simpl; auto.
  eapply forever_N_plus. eapply plus_right.
  eapply star_trans. eexact R. eexact T. reflexivity.
  simpl. left; eapply step_call; eauto. congruence. reflexivity.
  apply COF. eauto. traceEq.

(* statements *)
  intros. inv H.
(* do *)
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one; right; constructor.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => x); eauto. constructor. traceEq.
(* seq 1 *)
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one; right; constructor.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* seq 2 *)
  destruct (exec_stmt_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ H0 f (Kseq s2 k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto. inv B1.
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_right. eauto. right; constructor.
  reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* if test *)
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one; right; constructor.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => x); eauto. constructor. traceEq.
(* if true/false *)
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_right. eapply eval_expression_to_steps; eauto.
  right. eapply step_ifthenelse_2 with (b := b). auto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* return some *)
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one; right; constructor.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => x); eauto. constructor. traceEq.
(* while test *)
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one; right; constructor.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => x); eauto. constructor. traceEq.
(* while body *)
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_right. eapply eval_expression_to_steps; eauto.
  right; apply step_while_true; auto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* while loop *)
  destruct (exec_stmt_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ H2 f (Kwhile2 a s0 k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto.
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_trans. eapply eval_expression_to_steps; eauto.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_while_true; auto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  inv H3; inv B1; apply star_one; right; apply step_skip_or_continue_while; auto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* dowhile body *)
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one; right; constructor.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* dowhile test *)
  destruct (exec_stmt_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ H0 f (Kdowhile1 a s0 k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto.
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  eapply star_one. right. inv H1; inv B1; apply step_skip_or_continue_dowhile; auto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => x); eauto. constructor. traceEq.
(* dowhile loop *)
  destruct (exec_stmt_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ H0 f (Kdowhile1 a s0 k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto.
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  eapply star_left. right. inv H1; inv B1; apply step_skip_or_continue_dowhile; auto.
  eapply star_right. eapply eval_expression_to_steps; eauto.
  right; apply step_dowhile_true; auto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* for start 1 *)
  assert (a1 <> Sskip). red; intros; subst a1; inv H0.
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one. right. constructor. auto.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* for start 2 *)
  destruct (exec_stmt_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ H0 f (Kseq (Sfor Sskip a2 a3 s0) k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto. inv B1.
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; constructor. auto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  apply star_one. right; constructor.
  reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* for test *)
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one; right; apply step_for.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => x); eauto. constructor. traceEq.
(* for body *)
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; apply step_for.
  eapply star_right. eapply eval_expression_to_steps; eauto.
  right; apply step_for_true; auto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* for next *)
  destruct (exec_stmt_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ H2 f (Kfor3 a2 a3 s0 k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto.
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; apply step_for.
  eapply star_trans. eapply eval_expression_to_steps; eauto.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_for_true; auto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  inv H3; inv B1; apply star_one; right; apply step_skip_or_continue_for3; auto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* for loop *)
  destruct (exec_stmt_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ H2 f (Kfor3 a2 a3 s0 k)) as [S1 [A1 B1]]; auto.
  destruct (exec_stmt_to_steps _ _ _ _ _ _ H4 f (Kfor4 a2 a3 s0 k)) as [S2 [A2 B2]]; auto. inv B2.
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; apply step_for.
  eapply star_trans. eapply eval_expression_to_steps; eauto.
  eapply star_left. right; apply step_for_true; auto.
  eapply star_trans. eexact A1.
  eapply star_left.
  inv H3; inv B1; right; apply step_skip_or_continue_for3; auto.
  eapply star_right. eexact A2.
  right; constructor.
  reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
(* switch expr *)
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one; right; constructor.
  eapply COE with (C := fun x => x); eauto. constructor. traceEq.
(* switch body *)
  eapply forever_N_plus.
  eapply plus_left. right; constructor.
  eapply star_right. eapply eval_expression_to_steps; eauto.
  right; constructor. eauto.
  reflexivity. reflexivity.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.

(* funcalls *)
  intros. inv H.
  eapply forever_N_plus. apply plus_one. right; econstructor; eauto.
  eapply COS; eauto. traceEq.
Qed.

End BIGSTEP.

Whole-program behaviors, big-step style.


Inductive bigstep_program_terminates (p: program): trace -> int -> Prop :=
  | bigstep_program_terminates_intro: forall b f m0 m1 t r,
      let ge := globalenv p in
      Genv.init_mem p = Some m0 ->
      Genv.find_symbol ge p.(prog_main) = Some b ->
      Genv.find_funct_ptr ge b = Some f ->
      type_of_fundef f = Tfunction Tnil type_int32s cc_default ->
      eval_funcall ge m0 f nil t m1 (Vint r) ->
      bigstep_program_terminates p t r.

Inductive bigstep_program_diverges (p: program): traceinf -> Prop :=
  | bigstep_program_diverges_intro: forall b f m0 t,
      let ge := globalenv p in
      Genv.init_mem p = Some m0 ->
      Genv.find_symbol ge p.(prog_main) = Some b ->
      Genv.find_funct_ptr ge b = Some f ->
      type_of_fundef f = Tfunction Tnil type_int32s cc_default ->
      evalinf_funcall ge m0 f nil t ->
      bigstep_program_diverges p t.

Definition bigstep_semantics (p: program) :=
  Bigstep_semantics (bigstep_program_terminates p) (bigstep_program_diverges p).

Theorem bigstep_semantics_sound:
  forall p, bigstep_sound (bigstep_semantics p) (semantics p).
Proof.
  intros; constructor; intros.
(* termination *)
  inv H. econstructor; econstructor.
  split. econstructor; eauto.
  split. apply eval_funcall_to_steps. eauto. red; auto.
  econstructor.
(* divergence *)
  inv H. econstructor.
  split. econstructor; eauto.
  eapply forever_N_forever with (order := lt).
  apply lt_wf.
  eapply evalinf_funcall_steps; eauto.
Qed.
Generated by coq2html